Jesse’s Favorites of 2021

Welcome! It’s that time of year again – the time when we get to look back on the past year and reflect on which parts of it were most meaningful to us. One of my favorite ways to do this is by listing the five music albums, five books, and five movies that were most impactful and inspiring to me during the past year. I hope this list will both encourage you to check out some great works of art and challenge you to create your own favorites lists. So, without further ado, here we go!

Music Albums
Total listened to: 55

Honorable Mention: Modern Vampires of the City by Vampire Weekend, Divinely Uninspired to a Hellish Extent by Lewis Capaldi, The Ghost of Tom Joad by Bruce Springsteen, Songs in the Key of Life by Stevie Wonder

5. The Wild Swan by Foy Vance – Which is more noteworthy: this album (a soulful, groovy, and wonderfully oddball blend of Irish folk and American roots music) or Foy Vance’s mustache? You be the judge.

4. The Mantis & the Moon by Son of Laughter – Not only is Chris Slaten’s voice easy on the ears, but the stories he tells strike a perfect balance between skillful poetry and heart-tugging insight. Producer Ben Shive’s orchestrations are a perfect complement to Slaten’s songs, creating a lush landscape of sound that reveals more intricacy with every listen.

3. The Land of Canaan by J Lind – When was the last time you heard an album of music that made you uncomfortable in a good way? In the follow-up to his brilliant album For What It’s Worth (which was my favorite album of 2020), J Lind leads listeners into the wilderness, exploring universal experiences of doubt, disillusionment, and despair through the eyes of Old Testament characters. Dodging simplistic answers, Lind challenges us to face up to feelings that we all too easily refuse to acknowledge. Along the way, he invites us to glimpse Christ with us on our journeys, sharing our full humanity in all its messiness, struggle, and glory.

2. Pet Sounds by The Beach Boys – If, like I once did, you hear the name “Beach Boys” and think of cheesy ballads about cars, girls, and surfing, then you need to check out Pet Sounds. I gave it a listen after learning that many consider it to be the greatest album of music ever made, and I’ve been re-listening ever since. Brian Wilson is one of the great musical geniuses of our time, and Pet Sounds was his first attempt to share his heart with the world through song. The story of the album’s creation is a fascinating account of mental illness, musical experimentation, and artistic collaboration. If you’re interested in digging into it, I’d recommend checking out the 2014 biopic Love & Mercy or the 2021 documentary Brian Wilson: Long Promised Road.

1. Father of the Bride by Vampire Weekend – My favorite musical discovery of the past year, Vampire Weekend’s highly anticipated and Grammy-winning fourth album is the band’s best work to date. Where Modern Vampires of the City was grim in it’s honest confrontation with mortality and spiritual angst, Father of the Bride feels like a rebirth – a coming-to-terms with the mystery, struggle, and resilient beauty of ordinary life. Weaving lyrics about personal heartache with reflections on global issues, imbuing these lyrics with Biblical imagery (listen for all the references to gardens, weddings, and new creation), and setting them to jubilant, danceable rhythms, Vampire Weekend creates an unforgettable listening experience that awakens our longing to put broken things to rights.

Books
Total read: 9

Honorable Mention: Becoming Mrs. Lewis by Patti Callahan

5. Dune by Frank Herbert – Like many others this year, I read the book in preparation for the movie (which turned out to be exhilarating, superbly-crafted sci-fi cinema). The book has its problems – underdeveloped and unrelatable characters, a hurried second half, and abstruse prose that all too often keeps the reader at arm’s length. However, it’s still a suspenseful, immersive, and visionary achievement in fantasy worldbuilding.

4. Surprised by Joy by C.S. Lewis – While I couldn’t follow all the British colloquialisms and literary allusions that C.S. Lewis packs his autobiography with, I still found it a witty and fascinating account of his conversion from atheism to Christianity. Lewis’s descriptions of the “inconsolable longing” that led him to God have had a deep influence on my own faith.

3. Through a Screen Darkly by Jeffrey Overstreet – Jeffrey Overstreet is one of my literary heroes. I’m a huge fan of his thoughtful movie reviews (which you can check out at his blog: Looking Closer with Jeffrey Overstreet), and it was delightful to read a book about movies and moviemaking that both celebrates Christian faith and challenges Christians to dig deeper into the artistic quality and craft of movies (which is frequently neglected or ignored by mainstream Christian film reviews). If you’re a movie buff like me, then you’ll love this book!

2. Gentle and Lowly by Dane Ortlund – Outside of the Bible, this is the best theological book that I’ve ever read. Drawing inspiration from Scripture and Puritan writings, Ortlund handles the truth of God’s radical love for sinners and sufferers like a multifaceted gem, exploring it with great care from multiple angles. Just when you think you’ve got a handle on the idea of grace, Ortlund shines a flashlight on the cobwebby corners of your soul, exposing the doubts and defenses that taint your perspective on Christ’s heart and inviting you to reexamine that heart with fresh eyes.

1. Born to Run by Bruce Springsteen – I admired Bruce Springsteen’s music after discovering his landmark album Born to Run, but this book (which shares the same title) is what made me a die-hard fan. One of America’s greatest troubadours, the man millions know as “The Boss” brings the same lyricism, candor, and ripped-from-the-guts enthusiasm to his autobiography that he does to his songwriting. I burned through this 528-page tome and found it a joy from start to finish. If you’re interested in learning more about Springsteen, or if you’ve never checked him out, this book is a great place to start.

Movies & TV Shows
Total seen: 39

Honorable Mention: Springsteen on Broadway, Infinity Chamber, A Man for All Seasons

5. News of the WorldThis tale of an orphaned girl raised by Native Americans and adopted by a grizzled Civil War veteran could have been so easily cheapened and sentimentalized. Thank goodness, it is filmed with remarkable understatement, patience, and attentiveness to detail. Tom Hanks is great as usual, but it is Paul Greengrass’s prowess as a director that pushes this film into my favorites of the year.

4. Trollhunters: Tales of Arcadia – In the same category as other recent animated series like Avatar: The Last Airbender, Gravity Falls, or Over the Garden Wall, this Netflix original series by director Guillermo del Toro is a wildly enjoyable fantasy ride punctuated here and there by moments of greatness. I appreciated the time given for characters and plot threads to develop, which enabled the storyline to suck me in and keep me invested.

3. Under African SkiesPaul Simon’s legendary Graceland album is still one of the most awe-inspiring things I’ve ever listened to, and this documentary about its controversial production and enduring legacy is no less fascinating. Tracing Simon’s decision to defy the United Nations and record with black musicians in Apartheid-era South Africa, Under African Skies is a stirring testament to the cross-cultural, boundary-breaking power of song.

2. Nomadland – Right up until December, I was confident that this movie about the wandering folk of contemporary America would top my year-end favorites list. Director Chloe Zhao is a student of Terrence Malick, and it shows in Nomadland’s vivid, meditative cinematography. She’s also a fantastic storyteller in her own right, and the directing awards she received (along with those won by lead actress Frances McDormand) were well-deserved. Straddling the line between particular and universal, Nomadland is a profound examination of humanity’s restless search for belonging. You can read a more in-depth review in my blog post: “Joy on the Journey: Chasing Sehnsucht in Chloe Zhao’s Nomadland.”

1. Calvary – Is John Michael McDonagh’s dark comedy about an Irish Catholic priest threatened with murder a Christmas movie? I’d argue so, and I’ll make that case in an upcoming blog post. In the meantime, I’ll say that Calvary was the most moving and surprising artistic discovery that I made during the past year. Presented in the style of a whodunnit detective story and bolstered by brilliant acting and scriptwriting, Calvary tackles exceedingly difficult subject matter with an astonishing amount of grace. The last 15 minutes of the film are immensely powerful. Be forewarned, the film is gritty and delves into painful issues like sexual abuse and suicide. However, it’s an honest, thought-provoking, and ultimately redemptive tale.

Joy in the Journey: Chasing Sehnsucht in Zhao’s “Nomadland”

“Home, is it just a word? Or is it something you carry within you?”

In the opening minutes of Chloe Zhao’s film Nomadland, we see these words inked on the arm of an Amazon employee named Angela, who is showing off tattoos to her new friend, Fern. It’s a quick scene that may not seem particularly noteworthy. However, nothing in this movie is extraneous or insignificant. The words of this tattoo present us with both a portent of what’s to come and the central tension of the entire film. Fern (played by Frances McDormand) has recently endured back-to-back tragedies: the death of her husband and the closing of her longtime job at a gypsum plant in Empire, Nevada. Very soon, she will swap her belongings for a van and adopt the life of a nomad, crisscrossing the western United States in search of work and roadside community. As she meets other nomads, she will face questions that are at once timely and timeless: Where in this rapidly-changing world do I belong? How do I put down roots when all that was familiar has washed away? Can home be found on the edges of the maps?

If you haven’t seen Nomadland yet, I heartily recommend it. The movie was named Best Picture at the 2021 Oscars, where McDormand and Zhao also won awards for acting and directing, respectively. I saw the film months ago, but I’m still thinking about it. Primarily, this is because it reminds me of someone who, on the surface, has little in common with the oddball wanderers of modern America: C.S. Lewis.

Shortly after seeing Nomadland, I started reading Lewis’s autobiography, Surprised by Joy. In that book, Lewis recounts his decades-long journey to faith in Christ, tracing the impact of a mysterious sensation that he calls “Joy.” Lewis compares Joy to the German word Sehnsucht, defining it as an “inconsolable longing” in the human heart for “we know not what.” What do the nomads of Zhao’s film have to do with Lewis’s Joy? I believe that Nomadland is packed with echoes of that bewildering, bittersweet desire. If we listen closely to those echoes, we can learn some profound things about both the nature of Joy and humanity’s search for that elusive destination: home.

Shaken Loose

shallow focus of white dandelion

According to C.S. Lewis, Joy is dynamic. It’s an elusive desire, which appears unexpectedly and vanishes far more quickly than we want it to. While it may be sparked by familiar things – an illustration in a book, the smell of morning mist, or a glimpse of distant hills – it always surprises and unsettles us, compelling us to find it again. This is because of both its fleeting nature and its unique intensity. Joy carries with it a sense of what Lewis calls “incalculable importance,” a transcendent spark that feels otherworldly and makes all other pursuits seem “insignificant in comparison.” Unlike other desires, we can’t manufacture or control it. As Lewis says, Joy “is never a possession, always a desire for something longer ago or further away or still ‘about to be.’” Joy is on the move, and it gets us moving, too. Once we’ve encountered it, we are never quite the same.

The characters in Nomadland (many of them played by real-life nomads) have varied reasons for leaving society behind. Like Fern, some are bereaved and unemployed. Others are battling depression, chronic illnesses, or symptoms of PTSD. Still others are pursuing adventure and a deeper, richer way of life. Despite their differences, all of them have been shaken loose from what was familiar, launched into uncharted territory by experiences that changed them, rendering them unable or unwilling to thrive in traditional settings. Chloe Zhao highlights their uniqueness with close-up camera shots that dwell on weathered skin, lines etched in faces, and the glow of restless eyes. At the same time, she invites us to empathize with them by lingering on numerous scenes of everyday life, work, and play. These mundane moments are punctuated here and there with scenes of astonishing beauty: buffalo rustling through a sea of tall grass, hundreds of birds wheeling in the air beside a cave wall, sunset blazing over the Badlands, and a desert sky splashed with starlight. Like our own stories, the lives of Zhao’s characters are multifaceted – slow and meandering and chock-full of ordinariness, yet also riven by glory.

Like Fern and her companions, those of us who have experienced what Lewis calls “the stab of Joy” and committed ourselves to pursuing its source are square pegs in round holes – what the Bible calls “sojourners and exiles” (1 Peter 2:11). Having tasted a desire that no earthly comfort can assuage, we are compelled into motion. Our starting points may be different, but our quest is the same. We are drawn inexorably onward, lured by a high and holy wind that fills us with longing for something else, something more, and something beyond. We have no hope of controlling that wind, but if we allow it to carry us, we may find ourselves swept to places and people we may never have expected to encounter. Like Fern, we may find ourselves shedding old goals, old entanglements, and old coping mechanisms in our efforts to track down that peculiar spark, yet also discovering new joys along the way. We may traverse the highways and byways of the world, but we are no longer “of the world” (John 17:6). We have been displaced.

On the Outside Looking In

brown and black butterfly on glass

In Surprised by Joy, C.S. Lewis describes Joy as an ache – a desire that, while pleasurable, is tinged with bitterness. This melancholy strain is not only a consequence of Joy’s absence, but is also an intrinsic part of Joy itself. Reflecting on his own experience of Sehnsucht, Lewis identifies the feeling as something “almost like heartbreak.” Elsewhere, he calls it “a single, unendurable sense of desire and loss.” Joy as Lewis defines it is interwoven with grief.

While Chloe Zhao’s film explores the appeals of life on the road, it refuses to romanticize the experiences of its subjects. Fern and her friends are vulnerable to many hardships, from difficulties finding stable work to the vicissitudes of the natural environment. Cinematographer Joshua James Richards underscores these struggles with camera shots that expose the vast, silent barrenness of the Badlands and the Arizona Desert. In such places, a broken van becomes a terrifying prospect. Fern’s relationships are laced with the sorrow of inevitable goodbyes. During one raw scene, her sister tells her, “I would have loved having you around all these years. You left a big hole by leaving.” Throughout the film, we see Fern repeatedly gravitating toward the firm beams and warm embers of family. Yet again and again, that old itch that Joni Mitchell dubbed “the urge for going” sends her retreating back into the wilderness. Frances McDormand’s performance here is masterful, betraying the depths of Fern’s yearning and grief in quiet, subtle expressions and the fires of a relentlessly searching gaze.

In the pages of Scripture, we learn that suffering is part and parcel of our journeys toward Joy. 1 Chronicles 29:15 connects life as a sojourner with the ache of continual transience: “Our days on the earth are like a shadow, and there is no abiding.” In his letter to the Jewish exiles, the Apostle Peter describes the Christian sojourn as a battleground, which is fraught with temptation and peril: “Beloved, I urge you as sojourners and exiles to abstain from the passions of the flesh, which wage war against your soul” (1 Peter 2:11). Like the characters of Zhao’s film, those of us who chase Joy into the wild must eventually confront the fact that our best efforts to achieve happiness are imperfect. Beauty crumbles away, the fires of longing fade with time, and our thirst for lasting fulfillment collides with the reality that this world isn’t as it should be. The bitter aftertaste of Joy reminds us that despite its glories, our road is a hard one, and we are far more distant than we thought from the source of our longing. Like Fern, who thumps against the glowing windows of home with the persistence of a wayward moth, we find ourselves on the outside looking in.

Called Home

black and white arrow sign

Musing on the strange character of Joy, C.S. Lewis describes the desire as something akin to memory: “All Joy reminds.” On the final page of his autobiography, he elaborates this idea by comparing Joy to a signpost. Unlike other desires, Joy doesn’t merely lead us to the physical object or experience that inspired it. Instead, it points beyond itself to something that is farther off and more difficult to name. What does Joy remind us of, and where is it pointing us? Lewis answers these questions in his book Mere Christianity: “If I find in myself desires which nothing in this world can satisfy, the only logical explanation is that I was made for another world.”

There is a reason why our encounters with Sehnsucht feel otherworldly. That ache is a memory of another time and place – an echo of the Eden that was lost when humanity disavowed its creator and a seismic evil sundered the cosmos, fracturing everything in its wake. It is also a signpost pointing us to a time and place yet to come – to Eden regained, healed of all the sin and sickness and sorrow that ravaged it. The Joy that Lewis writes about is a both a remnant of paradise lost and an invitation from the God who is making all things new again. In the last analysis, it’s a call to come home.

Near the beginning of Nomadland, a girl asks Fern if she is homeless. “No, I’m not homeless,” Fern replies. “I’m just houseless. Not the same thing, right?” Throughout the film, as we watch Fern roam from place to place, we’re invited to ask ourselves that very question. Is home a physical place, or is it something that we take with us? Can those without roots ever truly be at home in this world? While a lesser film would slap simplistic answers on those questions, Zhao’s movie challenges us to linger in spaces of tension, inviting us into the physical and existential wilderness that Fern and her friends must navigate. We’re encouraged to walk a mile in their shoes – to see ourselves as fellow sojourners, set adrift between the things we’ve left behind and the future we’re longing to participate in. As we read in Hebrews 13:14, those of us who await God’s new creation “do not have an enduring city, but we are looking for the city that is to come.” Like Fern, we’re still on the road.

Yet for those with eyes to see and ears to hear, there is profound consolation to be glimpsed in Nomadland, tattooed on an Amazon worker’s arm. In the Apostle John’s depiction of the New Jerusalem, we witness the ultimate balm for our homesickness: our savior, Jesus, dwelling among the people he has redeemed by his blood. He, more than any physical space, is our truest homethe source of our Joy and the satisfaction of our longings. What comfort does this vision offer us in our wilderness wanderings today? Elsewhere in the New Testament, Christians are told that the same savior who will one day welcome us home now lives within each of us by the power of the Holy Spirit. Faced with the questions posed by Angela’s tattoo, we can honestly answer, “Yes and amen.”Yes, home is just a word; more specifically, it is a name. And yes, it is also something we carry within us – a fellow traveler, who has promised to be with us “to the very end of the age” (Matthew 28:20). Reflecting on Nomadland and its resonances to Lewis’s Joy, we might find ourselves agreeing with the words of George MacDonald: “Yea, no home at last will do, but the home of God’s heart.”

The Music of the Mundane

It was almost the best day of his life. Joe Gardner, a resident of New York City, had spent most of his years teaching jazz band classes for middle-schoolers. The work had its own peculiar charm. Sure, the racket cooked up by distracted brains, untrained ears, and clumsy fingers could be grating. But there were moments of magic along the way: flickers of musical progress, sessions when the students caught some of Joe’s infectious enthusiasm for jazz, and a young prodigy named Connie whose soulful trombone playing reminded Joe of the day he first fell in love with music. However, despite those perks, the work remained a chore which competed for time and energy with Joe’s true passion: playing jazz piano. Year after year, Joe’s dream of lighting up the stage seemed increasingly unattainable, dwindling into the darkness like a missed subway car. But that all changed when a smooth audition landed him a gig with Dorothea Williams, the legendary trumpet virtuoso. Before the audition, life had been mundane and monotonous – a melody that puttered along and circled back with all the predictability of a broken record. The gig with Dorothea was a key change, infusing the melody with new colors and possibilities. “I was born to play,” Joe had told his students. At long last, he was finally on the brink of doing so. 

Then, on his way home from the audition, he fell into a manhole. 

In a sick twist, Joe found his soul on a cosmic conveyor belt, moving with countless other souls toward the blinding light of the “Great Beyond.” Desperate to escape his fate, Joe leaped off the belt and plummeted into the void, only to find himself landing with a thud in the “Great Before.” Here, new souls were mentored and given their traits before heading to earth. Mistaken for a mentor, Joe was tasked with training a notoriously difficult soul named 22, who had zero interest in life on earth. The job presented Joe with the makings of an escape plan. He would take 22 to earth to help her find her “spark,” the missing piece of her palette. In exchange, he would get a chance to locate and rejoin his body. It was almost too good to be true: for one, a chance to witness life firsthand before committing to it, and for the other, a second chance at a life snuffed out by bad luck. However, in their undercover journey to earth, both Joe and 22 would get far more than they bargained for. 

I’m a huge fan of Pixar’s latest film, Soul. While it may sound like heresy to you animated movie lovers out there, I must confess that I liked it even more than Pixar classics like Up, Inside Out, The Incredibles, Finding Nemo, and Toy Story (Now, before you hunt me down and burn me at the stake, hear me out). Sure, there are plot flaws and corny bits. Sure, the spirituality of the film is a hodgepodge of the sincere, the strange, and the schmaltzy. However, more than any other Disney or Pixar film that I’ve seen, Soul hit me in the heartstrings and swept me into its propulsive, wonderfully outlandish plot. It also did what the best art does, prompting me to pause and reevaluate my life with fresh eyes. As a follower of Jesus Christ, I was delighted to find echoes of the Gospel in the storyline. Specifically, I believe that Soul has some profound and deeply countercultural things to say about a topic that is frequently overlooked in modern storytelling: the magic (or, in this case, the music) of the mundane. 

Make Me Interruptible 

New York street during daytime

Despite his commitment to helping 22 find her spark, Joe Gardner’s journey to Earth is really motivated by one goal: find and rejoin his body at any cost. It’s a race against the clock, made all the more pressing by the Accountant who hunts the escaped souls in an effort to return them to the Great Before. However, as a newcomer to Earth, 22 is arrested by the strangeness of New York City – the stew of sights, smells, and sounds that flavors its hustle and bustle. Throughout the film, she stops to appreciate things that Joe hurries past in his frantic quest: seeds spinning down from the branches of trees, the aroma of fresh pizza, a busker singing on a subway platform, and the rush of air through a sidewalk grate. To Joe, these interruptions are both bewildering and irritating. To 22, they’re burning bushes: moments of astonishing beauty that demand her full attention. 

Like the streets of NYC, our society is characterized by relentless momentum. Efficiency is the name of the game. Whether by TV commercials and touchless technology, freeways and fast food, or sound bites and cellphone upgrades, we’re trained to expect results that fit neatly into our accelerating timetables. The quicker and more streamlined the path to our goals, the better. We plug in earbuds to drown out distractions, use GPS to avoid detours, and fill our spare hours with activity to minimize downtime. Unlike 22, we rarely pause to notice our surroundings, because slowing down is missing out. “Adventure is out there,” we tell ourselves, and we chase after it with everything we’ve got, hurdling over anything that threatens to waste our valuable time. Like Joe Gardner, our eyes are on the clock. 

During the summer and fall of 2017, I had the opportunity to live, work, and study with residents of a slum in a Southeast Asian megacity. While there, I was frequently surprised by my neighbors’ attitudes toward privacy. I’m an extrovert. I draw energy from being with people and get stir-crazy if I’m alone for too long. Nevertheless, I found myself getting annoyed when kids pounded on my door and poked their heads in during homework sessions, when neighbors sidled over to strike up chats while I was trying to read, or when late-night karaoke music came rumbling like thunder through the walls of my house. My neighbors in the slum used almost all of their spare time to do one thing: visit their neighbors. By contrast, I found myself coveting alone time like toilet paper in the spring of 2020. 

Early in my stay, I recall sitting with two of my Kiwi teammates before our weekly prayer time. One of them confessed her frustration with neighbors who showed up uninvited in her house at all hours of the day, seeking conversation or help or nothing in particular. Then, as our prayer time began, my teammate prayed this prayer: “Lord, help me be interruptible.” Listening to her, I was convicted and humbled. She wasn’t asking God for a break from interruptions. She was asking him for fresh perspective – for the grace to see these disruptions of her plans and projects as opportunities for relationship-building.

My teammate’s attitude was remarkably Christ-like. During his three-year ministry on Earth, Jesus was a busy man. There were disciples to train, crowds to teach, sick people to heal, religious leaders to infuriate, and many, many miles to travel (not to mention a world-saving mission that needed some attending to). Yet, in the Gospel of Mark, we see Jesus not only allowing himself to be interrupted, but even encouraging disruptions of his agenda. When his disciples shooed away a group of kids, dismissing them as an unnecessary distraction, Jesus called the children back and turned their interruption into a teaching moment (Mark 10:13-16). When some folks interrupted Jesus’s sermon by lowering their crippled friend through the roof, Jesus put his lesson on hold and took time to heal the man (Mark 2:1-12). When a woman interrupted Jesus’ meal to anoint his feet with perfume, Jesus defended her unusual action in front of his companions (Mark 14:1-9). And when a penniless, chronically ill woman tugged his robe in a crowded street, Jesus forced his disciples to stop and made time to chat with the woman, despite the fact that he’d been hurrying to the home of a wealthy dignitary (Mark 5:25-34). Jesus operated on a different timetable than the people around him. Like 22, he saw interruptions not as cause for irritation, but as moments of profound beauty and possibility. In his eyes, each and every moment was worthy of attention. 

Slowing down can be much harder than speeding up. I resonate with the lyrics of Half Alive’s song “Arrow”: “This heart is afraid to beat slowly / Miss a chance at what I could become / I know that I can’t run forever / But I can’t stand still for too long.” Life hurtles forward, and we’ve got to keep up. Yet, if we spent more time looking out our windows, bringing into focus the blur of colors and shapes rushing by outside them, I wonder what we’d see. Perhaps, we would glimpse some of the truth that Jesus tapped into: the reality that, as John Lennon sang, “Life is what happens to you while you’re busy making other plans” (or, as Vanessa Redgrave so eloquently put it in Letters to Juliet, “Life is the messy bits”). Pausing in our rush to adventure, we might start to wonder whether the interruptions around us might actually be adventures in disguise – an unexpected party of dwarves in our kitchen, summoning us into a quest for dragon gold. We might find ourselves agreeing with the words of C.S. Lewis, penned in a 1943 letter: 

The great thing, if one can, is to stop regarding all the unpleasant things as interruptions of one’s ‘own’ or ‘real’ life. The truth is of course that what one calls the interruptions are precisely one’s real life – the life God is sending one day by day. What one calls one’s ‘real life’ is a phantom of one’s own imagination.

Small Things Matter

pair of white-and-black Adidas NMD

As Joe and 22 travel through New York City, 22 ponders what her “spark” might be. Enraptured by her surroundings, she suggests that it might be eating pizza, or listening to music, or talking to strangers. Joe shoots these ideas down quickly. A spark is something extraordinary, he tells her – a purpose or passion that directs the course of one’s life. By contrast, the things that delight 22 are small, which makes them trivial. 

“Bigger is better” is a maxim that’s widely accepted in American society. We see it everywhere we look: in our multi-million dollar sports stadiums, in the lavish spectacles of our entertainment industry, in the frenetic calculations of our stock markets, and even in the products that we purchase from our local grocery stores (Costco, anyone?). It isn’t necessary for something to be physically big to fit the bill. If there’s anything cellphones have taught us, it’s that a shocking amount of stuff (most of which we never knew we needed or wanted) can be crammed into a tiny space. In addition to efficiency, our culture prizes productivity, influence, and recognition, values exemplified by the soaring skyscrapers of our urban centers and the ceaseless scrolling of our social media feeds. We’re trained to tabulate costs and benefits in our pursuit of maximized results. If an activity can’t be chalked up to a specific career goal, turned into profit, or shared with our Instagram followers, then it’s probably a waste of our time.

By contrast, when we examine the life of Christ, we meet a man who, by all earthly accounts, wasted a whole lot of time on a whole lot of trivial things. The Son of God could have chosen any form he wanted for his entrance into our world. Instead of racing to start his mission, as most of us would have done, he chose to spend thirty years living in the backwater town of Nazareth (Luke 2:39-40,52; 3:23). During those years, he followed in his father’s footsteps and learned carpentry (Mark 6:3), a blue-collar vocation that had no direct relevance to his future work of teaching and healing. Throughout his ministry, Jesus spent numerous days visiting homes, sharing meals, and attending festivities with common folk (Luke 7:36, 10:38-42, 22:7-13; John 2:1-2). He did this so often that the influential people of the day called him “a glutton and a drunkard” (Matthew 11:19). And while he could have commandeered chariots (of the regular or angelic variety) to spread his message as fast as possible, Jesus walked everywhere he went (which, unless he was an Olympic-level speed walker, took a considerable amount of time). If ever anyone had reason to hurry through life, it was Jesus. Yet, the Savior of the world moved at what many today would consider a snail’s pace, investing huge amounts of time in small-scale activities that produced no grand or even substantive results.

Earlier this year, one of my favorite artists made national news headlines for a very odd reason. Andy Gullahorn, a singer-songwriter based in Nashville, was interviewed by The Atlantic and CBS News regarding a high-five tradition that he started with his friend and fellow musician, Gabe Scott. Once a week, Andy and Gabe walk thirty minutes to give each other a high-five, which includes a unique snap and clap routine that they developed together. After high-fiving one another, they usually keep walking and make their way back home. They’ve been doing this for seven years. At first glance, the ritual seems silly and a bit superfluous. However, for the two friends, it has become deeply meaningful over time. Gabe was hospitalized recently with a severe form of encephalitis, which ravaged his brain and caused him to forget his entire life. Andy visited his buddy regularly in the hospital. Amazingly, while Gabe couldn’t recall anything about who he was, his body remembered the high-five ritual that he’d shared with his friend – snap, clap, and all. Gabe’s memory has returned slowly, filling in the gaps left by his brain infection. In a bizarre twist of fate, something as silly and superfluous as a weekly high-five became both a step toward recovery and the glue binding two friends together through a season of intense suffering. 

Why did Jesus devote so much time and energy to small things? Like Andy and Gabe, he knew that small things have a way of adding up over time, becoming meaningful in surprising ways. He knew that there is no hierarchy of events – that a human life is the sum of billions of individual moments, each one every bit as precious and meaningful as the one before. Like 22, Jesus rejoiced in simple things like good food, beautiful music, and conversations with strangers, not because these things were instrumentally valuable as a means to an end, but because they were intrinsically valuable as God-given gifts. He invited his followers to ask themselves whether, in their hurry to get busy and get ahead, they had been missing the innumerable gifts woven into the fabric of their lives. The Apostle Paul echoed Jesus’ attitude toward small things in his letter to the Corinthians: “So whether you eat or drink or whatever you do, do it all for the glory of God” (1 Corinthians 10:31). Paul’s words remind us that all of life – the big stuff and the small – is an opportunity to worship the Giver of all good things. Andy Gullahorn makes a similar observation in his song “Small Things Matter,” which was inspired by his high-five tradition with Gabe Scott:

So take a walk with me on Monday morning
Through the same old small streets of our neighborhood
Oh, it’s no marathon that ends in glory
But it’s good

My Hometown

assorted magazine lot on white and blue container

Near the beginning of Soul, on a conveyor belt bearing him toward the Great Beyond, Joe Garner vents his frustration at the accident that stole his longed-for gig with Dorothea Williams. “I’m due,” he says. “Heck, I’m overdue!…This can’t happen. I’m not dying today. Not when my life just started.” In Joe’s mind, everything before that fateful day had been a prelude. His “spark” had always been jazz piano. By contrast, his years in the classroom were a necessary evil – a tiresome stage of life that he’d always assumed would be temporary. Sure, the job had its moments. But it wasn’t living, not in the full-hearted, ravishing sense that Joe had anticipated a professional jazz gig would be. If his life ended before he could achieve his dream, then what had that life really amounted to?

I resonate deeply with Joe’s struggle. When I graduated from college several years ago, I was excited to find a job that I was passionate about. Aimless and yet eager to change the world for the better, I plunged into work in the foster care system. Very quickly, I learned that social work was a lot less glamorous than I had expected. There were endless stacks of documents to sign and file, countless conflicts to sort out, and dozens of days that left me feeling spent and discouraged. Soon after arriving, I started itching to move to greener grass. Yet, without clear alternatives, I found myself agreeing to stay for longer and longer periods of time. My restlessness intensified. Rather than pondering why God had given me the job, I fretted over skills I had that were going unused and imagined other vocations that would surely be more fulfilling. On TV, on Facebook, and in the streets around me, I saw people scrambling to escape the drudgery of their routines and to find jobs that they truly enjoyed (jobs which, according to Confucius, would keep them from ever having to work a day in their lives). Like Joe Gardner, I felt cheated, stuck in a monotone melody that was drowning out the strains of more promising tunes. Fulfillment was out there somewhere, and life was making me wait for it. The chorus of Half Alive’s “Arrow” captured my feelings perfectly: “The hardest place to be is right where you are / In the space between the finish and the start / It’s the arrow in your heart.” 

Joe Gardner is a nerdy fan of jazz. In the past several months, I’ve become a nerdy fan of Bruce Springsteen. Prior to 2018, I knew him only as the dude screaming “BORN IN THE USA,” who sounded like he’d had the dual misfortunes of swallowing a bucketful of gravel and setting his pants on fire. Then, I discovered his landmark album Born to Run, started reading his song lyrics, and burned through his 508-page autobiography. I’m currently working my way through his entire discography and thoroughly enjoying it. Springsteen is famous for writing songs that interrogate the American dream, exploring the tension between our country’s promises of a brighter tomorrow and the gritty realities of its streets, tenement halls, and factories. His songs are marked by a longing to escape the monotony of working class life and, at the very same time, a fascination with the mundane details of that life. Perhaps the best example of this paradox is his song “My Hometown.” The track opens with a tender father-son interaction:

I was eight years old and running with a dime in my hand
Into the bus stop to pick up a paper for my old man
I’d sit on his lap in that big old Buick and we’d steer as he drove through town
He’d tousle my hair, and say, “Son, take a good look around –
This is your hometown.” 

As the song progresses, Springsteen recounts the toll that changing times took on his hometown: the race riots that endangered innocent lives, the textile mill shutdown that stripped men of their jobs, and the gradual exodus of the town’s citizens. In the final verse, Springsteen confesses his longing to leave the town that has fallen so far short of his childhood dreams. Then, unexpectedly, he hits us with a twist:

Last night me and Kate, we laid in bed, talking about getting out
Packing up our bags, maybe heading south
I’m thirty-five, we’ve got a boy of our own now
Last night I sat him up behind the wheel and said, “Son, take a good look around – 
This is your hometown.” 

That final verse gets me every time I hear it, because the redemption in the lyrics is impossible to miss. Although thoroughly disenchanted with his hometown, Springsteen still feels an inexplicable loyalty to the place. He wills himself to see its landscape through new eyes: the eyes of his son. He seeks beauty in familiar streets. Ultimately, he recognizes that no hardship can sever the ties that bind him to his birthplace. Sure, it’s screwed up and run-down and a sorry excuse for what it was. But it’s home.

Springtseen reminds me of another storyteller who was fascinated by the mundane (Guess who?). During his time on Earth, Jesus spoke often about “the kingdom of God,” which he described as God’s reign in human hearts. To illustrate what this kingdom was like, he told stories called “parables.” These parables included many images that were familiar to Jesus’ listeners: birds in trees, farmers sowing seeds, wheat fields at harvesttime, yeast rising in dough, village markets, and fishermen casting their nets (Matthew 13:31-33, 45-50; Mark 4:26-29). According to Jesus, God’s redemptive work in the world was transformative, unpredictable, and mysterious. Yet, the images that he chose to depict it were remarkably commonplace. 

Why would Jesus describe a reality as lofty as God’s kingdom in such mundane terms? One reason is that Jesus himself was raised in a poor, rural context, so these scenes were familiar to him. However, I believe there’s a deeper answer. Jesus told tales about simple, monotonous, ordinary life because that is where the kingdom of God is built. To people who had been told that “important” things happened elsewhere, in cities and fortresses and halls of power, Jesus delivered a summons to God’s work in the here and now, wherever that happened to be: “…the kingdom of God is in your midst” (Luke 17:21). To those who dreamed of future exploits while griping about their present duties, he issued a challenge to glimpse God’s hand in the daily grind, whether that grind took place in a wheat field, in foster care, in an abandoned factory town, or in a middle-school jazz band classroom. Jesus wanted people to see that no location is devoid of God’s presence, that no soul is free from God’s purpose, and that no task, however menial, is exempt from God’s call to service and self-sacrifice. According to Christ, God’s kingdom isn’t nearly as noisy and self-important as the kingdoms of this world. It doesn’t have to be. Rather, as Jean Marc Ela writes in African Cry, the road to redemption is “gestated in the deeds of the everyday” – paved with countless quiet acts of humility and faithfulness, right where we are. 

The End of All Our Exploring

train approaching near high-rise buildings

Have you ever wondered why “coming full circle” is an element of so many stories? Why do so many heroes and heroines set off on quests into the unknown, only to eventually find themselves right back where they started? While I’m no literary theorist, one possible explanation is that storytelling itself is a circular act. By yanking us out of our worlds for a little while and then plopping us back into them, stories invite us to reexamine our surroundings with fresh eyes. When we read about Harry Potter stepping off his train into King’s Cross Station, or about the Pevensie children tumbling out of the wardrobe into the Professor’s house, or about Frodo and his friends riding into the Shire, we aren’t meant to mourn the loss of these fantasy worlds. Rather, we’re meant to take another look at the world around us – that same old world that is shattered by sin and suffering and yet somehow still brimming with promise, if only we had eyes to see it. In tales like these, we’re reminded that the very places we so often yearn to escape from are the arena of God’s kingdom activity. Like J.K. Rowling, C.S. Lewis, and J.R.R. Tolkien, Christ whispers to our hearts in the language of story, inviting us to come full circle and rediscover the magic of ordinary life. Perhaps, as Frederick Buechner suggests in his book Wishful Thinking, that life was never really ordinary, after all: 

If you think you are seeing the same show all over again seven times a week, you’re crazy. Every morning you wake up to something that in all eternity never was before and never will be again. And the you that wakes up was never the same before and will never be the same again. 

This, in the end, is why I’m such a huge fan of Pixar’s Soul. As I watched the mind-bending, metaphysical quest of Joe Gardner and 22, I was filled with gratitude for the miraculous world that I inhabit and for the Savior who entered into that world. Like 22, Jesus took a crash course in what it means to be human. He embraced life on this planet with all its quirks and repetitiveness, its delights and heartaches. He chose to walk our streets – to share the drudgery that is part and parcel of our everyday existence. He made our hometown his hometown. In doing so, he taught us that each and every facet of our surroundings, from the starry heavens down to the grime of the soil, is steeped in glory. In Pixar’s Soul and Jesus’s humanity, we’re challenged to listen to the mundanity of our lives and to hear the music that’s always been going on there – in the interruptions, in the small things, and in the places we call home. As T.S. Eliot wrote in his poem The Four Quartets,

We shall not cease from exploration
And the end of all our exploring 
Will be to arrive where we started
And know the place for the first time

Jesse’s Favorites of 2020

Hello there!

Well, it’s time for my favorite year-end activity: the annual favorites list! In many ways, 2020 was an incredibly tough year for art and artists. On the other hand, I found that quarantine provided lots of downtime to make art, explore new art, and catch up on great art that I’d missed in previous years. In terms of art discovery, this year was a treasure trove. I came across quite a few books, movies, and music albums that jumped straight into my all-time favorites lists, and many more that I thoroughly enjoyed (and a few that I thoroughly hated…). I hope this list can serve as a launching pad for your own exploration and discovery. So, without further chinwagging, here’s the list!

Books

Total read: 15

Honorable Mentions: The Cymbal Crashing Clouds: Companion Book by Ben Shive, The Faithful Spy: Dietrich Bonhoeffer and the Plot to Kill Hitler by Alex Berenson, Fiddler’s Gun by A.S. Peterson, Poverty Creek Journal by Thomas Gardner

#5. I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings by Maya Angelou 
If you’re like me, your high school English teacher mentioned this book, and you filed it under the “Maybe Sometime in the Distant Future” part of your brain. Well, I finally got around to it, and now I know what all the fuss is about. A bold, hilarious, evocative, and impassioned memoir of life in the Jim-Crow era segregationist south, with far too many wonderful sentences to count (trust me, I tried writing them down and gave up when there were too many). 

#4. “Leaf by Niggle” by J.R.R. Tolkien
If you’re a fan of Tolkien’s work, if you’re an aspiring artist, or if you’ve ever wrestled with the tension between lofty goals and hard realities, then this gem of a short story is for you. Tolkien penned it during a time of intense discouragement, when he wondered whether he’d ever finish his life’s work (which eventually became The Lord of the Rings), and it became a source of hope that enabled him to keep going. For that, I’m deeply grateful!

#3. Adorning the Dark by Andrew Peterson 
There’s probably no person who has influenced my own sense of artistic vocation more than Andrew Peterson. So when I heard that the singer-songwriter and author of The Wingfeather Saga had written a book about the artist’s vocation, I was a tad bit excited. In a year when I was wrestling with difficult questions about my purpose, gifts, and aspirations, this book couldn’t have come at a better time. 

#2. Telling the Truth: The Gospel as Tragedy, Comedy, & Fairytale by Frederick Buechner
Yup, it’s every bit as good as the title makes it sound. A gifted lecturer, pastor, and novelist, Frederick Buechner tells Bible stories with surprising modern twists that engage the mind, tug the heartstrings, and kindle the imagination all at once. Here’s a book to be savored slowly, preferably on rainy nights with a cup of very strong coffee. 

#1. Jayber Crow by Wendell Berry
On the surface, Wendell Berry’s Jayber Crow and J.R.R. Tolkien’s Lord of the Rings are about as different as two stories could be – one an epic tale of quests and battles in a sprawling fantasy realm, one the memoirs of a bachelor barber who lives almost his entire life in the same tiny farming town in Kentucky. Yet, beneath the surface differences, the two stories share a beating heart. Beyond the remarkable attention to detail and the fierce and abiding love for the earth, both of these works are ultimately about fellowship, in the deepest and truest sense of that word. Jayber Crow is the first book that I feel fully comfortable ranking alongside The Lord of the Rings in my list of all-time favorites, which is the highest compliment that I can give. 

Music Albums:

Total listened to: 35

Honorable Mention: Jesus is King by Kanye West, The Desired Effect by Brandon Flowers, Saturday Nights & Sunday Mornings by Counting Crows, Surprise by Paul Simon, Everyday Life by Coldplay, Fever Breaks by Josh Ritter, Leave What’s Lost Behind by Colony House

#5. Desolation and Consolation by Drew Miller
Grappling head-on with weighty topics – loneliness, disillusionment, grief, and mortality, to name a few – Drew Miller’s songs explore the redemptive hope of the gospel in ways that are nuanced rather than simplistic, honest rather than sentimental, and ultimately deeply comforting. I marvel at the economy of his lyrics, which cover so much ground and yet flow so beautifully. 

Song to check out: “Into the Darkness”

#4. Crooked by Propaganda
If there’s a record that I’d recommend to every American seeking to process the events of 2020, this would be it. While it’s a blistering, brutally candid account of our nation’s crookedness, it’s ultimately a record about crooked things being set right. This album is a tour-de-force, balancing epic scope with concrete imagery, tongue-in-cheek humor with historical analysis, social criticism with personal confession, old-school rap and hip-hop with Prop’s signature spoken word, and unflinching honesty with the full-bodied hope of the gospel.

Song to check out: “It’s Not Working”

#3. Now, Not Yet by Half Alive
Props to my buddy Aaron for introducing me to this one. I’m so dang proud of these guys for making this record – for setting their sights so high and taking so many creative risks in their efforts to say something true and beautiful. It’s as if the band was tracking my thoughts, questions, longings, and struggles throughout 2020 and decided to make an entire album based on what they saw, just for the heck of it. Every track makes me want to dance, both because the tunes are ridiculously groovy and because of those glorious music videos. Well done, lads. 

Song to check out: “Still Feel”

#2. Dream War by Ella Mine
This one inspired one of my most recent blog pieces: “Dreaming in the Depths: Ella Mine and the Problem of Overwhelming Suffering.” It also brought me to tears twice, which is pretty darn unusual (only one other record has ever managed that: Andy Gullahorn’s recent album Everything as It Should Be). As someone who has struggled with debilitating mental illness, I resonated deeply with the story of brokenness and recovery that Ella Mine tells. Her album is unlike anything else I’ve heard – a haunting, dreamlike landscape of classical piano, alternative rock, and Celtic folk that 100% works. This one needs to be listened to front to back, with no interruptions. I’d also recommend checking out the story behind the album before you listen, as it provides context which enriches the listening experience (You can find her story here: https://rabbitroom.com/2019/10/dream-war-an-interview-with-ella-mine/). 

Song to check out: “Wheel of Love”

#1. For What It’s Worth by J Lind
If I had to predict which album from the past year I’ll revisit most often in years to come, this would be it. Inspired by J Lind’s work alongside hospice patients, the album’s songs explore the theme that has resurfaced most often in my own heart over the years: the tension between the world’s deep beauty and deep brokenness. With graceful lyrics and instrumentation that is captivating yet unobtrusive, J Lind draws us into a journey from the highways of Nashville to a distant fantasy kingdom, from the far reaches of outer space to the jungles and slums of India, and from the starlit sea to a hospice bedside. Each song on the record is a uniquely beautiful, self-contained gem, and yet the songs weave together to form an intricate whole that is more than the sum of its parts. Not to mention, this album inspired a blog piece that may be my favorite thing I’ve ever written: “Brokenness, Beauty, and the Ballad of Samwise Gamgee.”

Song to check out: “Letter to the Editor”

Special Honorable Mention: “Sing Gently” by Eric Whitacre’s Virtual Choir 6
I don’t know what to say about this song, except that it’s a miracle and the closest thing to heaven I’ve ever encountered in music. I watched the video probably fifteen straight times after seeing it for the first time. And the best part…(drumroll, please)… my brother and his girlfriend are in it! 

Movies:

Total seen: 55

Honorable Mention: 1917, My Neighbor Totoro, Won’t You Be My Neighbor, 13th, A Quiet Place, Downton Abbey, Knives Out, Tree of Life, Hamilton, Munyurangabo, Princess Mononoke, Doctor Strange

#5. The Secret of Kells 
Featuring intricate, hand-drawn animation inspired by medieval illustrations, lovable characters, a soaring Celtic soundtrack, and a profound story about the value of art and beauty in dark times, this film would easily claim the title of my all-time favorite animated movie…. if not for another item on this list. It inspired a blog piece that I wrote around St. Patrick’s day and the onset of COVID-19, called “The Celts, the Coronavirus, and the Kingdom of God.” 

#4. Tolkien
Until watching this movie, I’d never realized how profound and far-reaching J.R.R. Tolkien’s impact on the course of my life has been. His books are the reason I first fell in love with literature and storytelling as a little kid. And the presence of his desk and pen in a museum at Wheaton College was one of the main reasons I chose to study English at that school, where I met a group of friends who became the closest thing to Frodo’s fellowship that I’ve ever known (most of them Tolkien fans as well!). God used this lovely, under-the-radar film to help me celebrate and bid farewell to that special time, to rekindle my love for language and story, and to cement the sense of calling that he’d been nudging me towards all year. Watching the movie felt a lot like reconnecting with an old friend, like sharing the best kind of inside joke, and ultimately like coming home again. 

#3. Spirited Away
Okay, Studio Ghibli fans… call me late to the party. I’ve been listening and re-listening to this movie’s soundtrack since the autumn. I’ve watched behind-the-scenes videos while scribbling details in my notepad. And on a car ride through Pennsylvania with one of my best friends, we discussed the film’s plot at high speed for about an hour and a half. All that to say, I’ve never been more gobsmacked, fascinated, moved, and inspired by a work of animation. Hats off to you, Hayao Miyazaki. 

#2. Paterson
This film jumped into my top 5 favorite movies of all time almost instantly. It hurts my heart to rank it second on this list, because I love every single thing about it: the wonderfully quirky and relatable characters (including Adam Driver in his most un-Kylo-Ren performance to date), the loving attention to mundane details, the thoughtful and understated storyline (which flows along gently like the poems penned by its bus-driving hero), the off-beat humor, and the profound take on the artist’s vocation (which is the best I’ve seen in a film). The last ten minutes of the movie are sheer perfection. 

#1. A Hidden Life
How to put this one into words? Nothing I say could begin to do it justice. I’ll just mention that I saw it 3 times in theaters, dragging different people along each time, and that it’s the most beautiful, worshipful, and emotionally resonant thing I’ve ever seen on the big screen. If you go into it expecting a typical Hollywood ride, with all the usual bells and whistles, you’ll almost certainly be disappointed. But if you go into it with an open heart, expecting to learn and grow, to be challenged to think and feel in unconventional ways, and to reflect on what makes you own life worth living, then I guarantee you won’t forget this one any time soon. You can read a more detailed review in my blog piece: “The Way of the Cross: Glimpsing Christ in A Hidden Life”

The Greatest Joke Ever Told

If you asked any of my family members to describe my grandfather, it wouldn’t take long for them to mention his laugh. 

As an author and former preacher, Grandpa Hayden had lots of opportunities to practice the art of storytelling. As an instigator of shenanigans in his younger years, he also had lots of fuel for his tales. Some of my most treasured memories are of sitting with my grandparents, listening to Grandpa tell stories that only he could tell. There was the time when Grandpa and his friends put rubber-soled shoes on a greased pig and then released the animal into their college’s freshman gala. There was the time when Grandpa tried to extinguish a flaming car engine and ended up tripping and drenching himself with the hose instead. There was the time when Grandpa and a buddy woke up to find themselves driving through a cornfield, and Grandpa turned to his friend and said the first words that popped into his head: “So…do you come here often?”. And there was the time when Grandpa’s friend was traveling to meet his girlfriend’s family, and Grandpa gave him a lift on his motorcycle, only to have the bike malfunction on the way and spurt gasoline all over them, so that they pulled into the girlfriend’s driveway with their pants on fire. Inevitably, as Grandpa told these stories, he would start laughing – a warm, wheezy laugh that bubbled up from deep inside him like an undigested burrito, making his whole body shake. Often, he’d wind up laughing so hard that he’d be unable to finish the story. For my siblings and I, that laugh was an even better reward than the punchline. 

What is it about stories like this that makes us laugh? While I’m no humor guru, I think the answer lies somewhere along the lines of this quote by James Bryan Smith, from his biography of singer-songwriter Rich Mullins: “A good joke is all about the surprise; we never see it coming. And humor is based on incongruity, about something being out of place…” Each of the stories above contains an unexpected scenario. Each of them also involves something out of place: a greased pig at a gala, a man spraying himself with a hose while an engine burns next to him, a car in a cornfield, and a grand entrance marred by flaming pants. The set-up is important, too: anticipation must be built for the punchline to land effectively. When all of these ingredients are present, a good joke pops and sizzles like a firecracker. When they’re absent, a joke falls flat, as sad and underwhelming as a deflated whoopee cushion. 

When we think about the Christmas story, I’d be willing to bet that most of us don’t think about jokes or laughter. The narratives of Christmas are marked by many different emotions: fear on the faces of the shepherds, awe and wonder on the faces of the wise men, murderous rage on the face of King Herod, tender affection on the faces of Mary and Joseph. But in most of our storybook illustrations and nativity scenes, laughter is conspicuously absent. We may laugh during our Christmas festivities, but when we turn to Scripture, a demeanor of solemn reverence is often the order of the day. Describing the Christmas story as humorous may seem irreverent. Calling it a joke might seem downright sacrilegious. However, when we examine the accounts of Jesus’ birth in the gospels, we find that the ingredients of a good joke are all present there. In fact, they’re startlingly apparent. 

Let’s look at the set-up. At the time of Jesus’ birth, the people of Israel were ready for a change. For centuries, Israel’s prophets had foretold the coming of a Messiah – a divinely appointed king who would rescue and redeem the Jewish nation. The Israelites had clung to these promises through wars and rebellions, through exile in foreign lands, and finally through subjugation at the hands of the Roman Empire. In earlier times, when their land was safe and prosperous, God’s promises of coming deliverance might have seemed superfluous, like sleep to a first-year college student. But after centuries of hardship, the Jews were waiting with bated breath. They yearned for a warrior king who could liberate them from oppression. Anticipation was so high that some people had begun claiming to be the Messiah, risking execution in their efforts to resist Roman tyranny. Tensions between the conquerors and the conquered had reached their boiling point. In terms of building suspense, God couldn’t have chosen a better time to deliver his punchline. 

How about surprise? The gospels of Matthew, Luke, and John record six different angelic visits during the time of the Nativity, which usually scared the living daylights out of whoever was present to witness them (the shepherds in particular got hit with a heavenly spotlight that probably sent their sheep into a coma). We witness Mary’s shock at being told she’s going to have a baby, in spite of everything she knows about how human biology works. We see a caravan of magicians from the East, trekking after a star that most certainly wasn’t labeled in their astronomy textbooks. The gospel authors emphasize their characters’ bewilderment at these events, just in case we forgot that such things don’t happen on a typical Tuesday. 

Then there’s incongruity. You might think that the long-awaited Messiah would come from prestigious stock – maybe royal family, or at least one of the wealthy and distinguished clans of Israel. Instead, Mary and Joseph are so poor that they can only afford the most meagre offering at their son’s temple dedication. You might think the Messiah would choose an impressive place for his grand entrance, like the royal palace or the Jewish temple. Instead, he’s born in a barn, surrounded by hay and manure and cows who, while intrigued by the scene, probably had less pressing matters on their minds. You might think the Messiah’s arrival would be heralded by fanfare – trumpets and crowds and dignitaries clambering for a photo-op. Instead, the first ones to visit him are shepherds, who no one (excepting, perhaps, their sheep) would ever picture as the creme de la creme of Israelite society.

Beyond these puzzling circumstances, there’s the greatest incongruity of all: the identity of the babe in the manger. In the prologue to John’s gospel, we discover that Jesus wasn’t just a deliverer sent from God, but rather God himself, come to deliver his people. In order to accomplish his rescue mission, God had taken on human flesh. Christians refer to this miraculous event as the Incarnation. Think about it: If you knew that the creator of the world was coming to save that world, what form might you expect him to take when he arrived? A blazing inferno, perhaps? A thundering voice to rattle the roots of the mountains? A majestic commander flanked by legions of angels? How about a baby – a helpless newborn flailing his arms, crying for milk, and soiling himself on the regular? As crazy as it sounds, this is the way that God Almighty makes his entrance into the world: with a poopy diaper. It’s an entrance every bit as startling as flaming pants. The more you think about it, the more laughable it becomes. James Bryan Smith summarizes this strange scene well when he writes, 

The Incarnation is really God’s great joke, in the best sense of the word…Except for the cryptic words of the prophets, we could never have seen the Incarnation coming. It does seem an odd way to save the world. It is incongruous – God cannot become enfleshed, much less as a baby…crazier still, in a barn. The King of kings and Lord of lords is lying in a feeding trough between an ox and an ass looking on with furrowed brow.

What significance does “God’s great joke” have for our lives? Why is it important for us to glimpse the humor in the Christmas story? If we’re honest, we have to admit that our lives are marked by incongruity. Each of us lives with the tension between our hopes and our realities – the world we long for and the one we actually inhabit. Life as we know it is a constant tug-of-war between delight and heartache. In his book Telling the Truth: The Gospel as Tragedy, Comedy, & Fairy Tale, Frederick Buechner argues that this struggle is visible in the similarities between laughter and weeping. While these responses center on different emotions, both of them well up from deep inside us, generate involuntary sounds, cause our bodies to shake, and bring us to tears. According to Buechner, these similarities are not accidental. Both laughter and weeping come from the deepest part of our hearts – the place of our most cherished hopes and our most palpable frustrations. 

In the struggle between laughter and weeping, the odds seem stacked in weeping’s favor. According to Buechner, “To weep at tragedy…is to weep at that which is inevitable.” Despite our best efforts to make the world a better place, our daily news is still stuffed with tragic headlines: violence and viruses, death and disaster, corruption and chaos. Whether by our own hardships or the hardships of others, we’re trained to “hope for the best, but expect the worst.” For many, the year 2020 has only served to clarify and intensify this cynicism. Disillusionment and despair are the order of the day. 

Like us, the Jews of Jesus’ day had many reasons to be cynical. Christmas carols have made much of the dark environment that Christ entered into – a context rife with political unrest, injustice, and brutality. Yet, in the midst of this hostile setting, we witness a response from the world’s maker that, in many ways, seems profoundly silly. Why would God concoct such a laughable plan in the face of the world’s great darkness? 

For years, my favorite Christmas tune has been Rich Mullins’s song “You Gotta Get Up (Christmas Song).” The song opens with imagery of a kid shaking his parents awake on Christmas morning, eager to open presents. It’s a scene that, while warm and fuzzy for most of us, is also familiar and mundane. Christmas rolls around every year, sometimes joyful, sometimes busy and frenetic, sometimes gloomy, always filled with the same old traditions and decorations and foods. After anticipating his presents, the child in the song starts to ponder the Christmas story. Mullins narrates the child’s thoughts in his scratchy smoker’s voice, “Oh, I hope there’ll be peace on earth / I know there’s goodwill toward men / On account of that baby born in Bethlehem.” Suddenly, the folksy piano and guitar that have undergirded the song drop away, and we hear the otherworldly sound of a Celtic pipe, ringing high and clear over a tune that all at once feels quite unfamiliar. I’ve listened to this song dozens and dozens of times, and that little segment still catches me by surprise and tugs on my heartstrings every time I hear it.

By lulling us in with familiar Christmas imagery, then sucker-punching us with Celtic pipes (which, in my humble opinion, are the king of musical sucker-punches), Mullins challenges us to reexamine our familiar Christmas routines and to glimpse the magic there. It’s as if he’s throwing open the shutters of our houses and dragging us to the window, inviting us to see the glittering expanse of snow that surrounds us, if only we had eyes to see it. In a way, his song is an answer to the question posed above, regarding the silliness of Christ’s birth. Like the strange circumstances of the Incarnation, it invites us to stop and peer beneath the surface – to question whether, in our preoccupation with comfort and normalcy and outward appearances, we’ve missed something truly remarkable. 

While I don’t think we’ll ever unravel the mystery of the Incarnation, I believe the infant Christ reveals that, despite all appearances to the contrary, goodness and innocence and delight are deeper and weightier truths than evil and sorrow and suffering. The candles of our love and laughter may seem pitiful against the tide of darkness that surrounds us. However, in the Incarnation, we see that they’re only reflections of a fiercer and holier light, which burns in the very heart of God himself. John describes Christ this way in the prologue to his gospel: “In him was life, and that life was the light of all mankind. The light shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it” (John 1:4-5). In the midst of suffering and sorrow, the God of heaven can laugh because he’s telling the story, and he knows the ending. He knows that the future which is coming – the redemption and renewal that Christ had come to accomplish for his people – is something so beautiful that the only proper response from us is incredulous laughter, laughter to the point of tears. He knows that the brokenness of this world is temporary – that, as Andrew Peterson sings, “all the death that ever was, if you set it next to life…would barely fill a cup.” The Incarnation is a window into the heart of things. Peering into that place, the place from which our laughter and weeping well up together, we discover that laughter wins the day. Frankly, it isn’t even close. 

2020 has been a difficult year if there ever was one. We have lots of good reasons to be solemn and cynical. And yet, this Christmas (and every Christmas, for that matter), God invites us to laugh at the incongruous scene in the manger – to see it as the greatest of all jokes, designed to bring about our deepest delight. Like my grandfather, laughing himself to the point of tears before he even gets to the punchline, we can laugh in the here and now, because we know where the story is headed. In the end, maybe the joke shouldn’t be so surprising, after all. As Frederick Buechner writes,

I have spoken of tragedy as inevitable and comedy as unforeseeable and seen from the inside of each, that seems to me to be so…But seen from the outside, seen as God sees it and as occasionally by the grace of God man also sees it, I suspect that it is really the other way around. From the divine perspective, I suspect that it is the tragic that is seen as not inevitable whereas it is the comic that is bound to happen. The comedy of God’s saving the most unlikely people when they least expect it, the joke in which God laughs with man and man with God – I believe that this is what is inevitable…

Dreaming in the Depths: Ella Mine and the Problem of Overwhelming Suffering

Have you ever been blindsided by something that left you feeling completely helpless?

On a windy afternoon in the autumn of 2017, I was caught off guard by a huge wave while bodysurfing in the Indian Ocean. I’d been catching waves with a friend for a long time that day and was having a blast. As each wave approached, I turned my back to it and leaned forward, bracing for the impact that would launch me toward shore. The speed generated by the breakers was exhilarating. I loved the feeling of knifing through space with a tunnel of water surging around me. 

The wave that blindsided me looked just like all the others had, and I braced for it like I had dozens of times before. But this time, I got the timing all wrong. Instead of propelling me forward, the wave came down hard on my shoulders, plunging me below the surface. My nose and mouth flooded with seawater, and I found myself tumbling across the sandy bottom of the inlet, clawing at the sand in a vain attempt to slow myself down. At one point, the water slammed my head into the sand and swept the rest of my body over it, and I felt and heard a sickening crunch in my neck. When the wave finally receded, I lurched to my feet and stumbled away from the water. I didn’t try any more bodysurfing on that trip. For two days, I couldn’t open my mouth without deep pressure and pain in the hinges of my jaw. Thankfully, these sensations disappeared with time. To this day, I have no idea what happened in my neck and jaw that afternoon. I don’t doubt that the force of that wave could’ve snapped my neck, and I’m grateful that God kept that from happening. But I still remember what it felt like to be caught in the clutches of the sea – that terrifying loss of control at the hands of a wave which didn’t know or care that I existed. 

For many people, the past year has felt an awful lot like the experience I just described. 2020 will go down in history as a year of profound disorientation – a year that blindsided us all, sweeping us along with all the force of a tidal wave. Taken alone, each of the year’s crises – COVID-19, hurricanes and wildfires, police brutality and riots, political corruption and polarization – would be exhausting. Taken together, these events have left many people feeling bewildered and adrift, tossed about like flotsam in a churning sea.

When I first heard Ella Mine’s debut album Dream War earlier this year, I didn’t recognize its deep relevance to this particular season of disorientation. The first thing that struck me about the album was the genius of the music: the enchanting blend of alt rock and classical piano and Irish folk, the perfect synthesis of tunes and lyrics, the way the songs flow into and build upon one another (honestly, it’s one of the most well-crafted records I’ve ever heard). The second thing that struck me about it was the intimacy of the tale being told. Mine penned the album’s songs during her recovery from a season of severe mental illness. In an interview with Chris Thiessen of the Rabbit Room, she described the experience this way: 

I was diagnosed with a pain condition called Central Sensitization Syndrome when I was 17. To help with the pain, I was prescribed an SSRI designed to treat depression, but commonly offered off-label for physical pain like mine. After two months, my personality was completely altered. It took me and the people around me completely off guard. We didn’t know that the medication would have psychoactive effects. I became apathetic and hateful, two emotional states I had never experienced before. It was terrible. I got off the SSRI slowly, thinking, “Now I’ll get back to normal.” Sadly, that’s often not how it works. Getting off the medication was even worse. I experienced psychosis, a confusing, terrifying state where I didn’t know what was true and what wasn’t. Visual and auditory hallucinations made it difficult to know whether or not what I was seeing or hearing was real. The drug also caused akathisia and mild cognitive impairment that made math, logic, and even speaking difficult. I had compulsions and impulses that were completely foreign and terrifying. That’s hard to live through. At that point, it’s a choice to keep living. And five years later, I’m still on an incline of recovery. (Read the rest of the interview here:The Rabbit Room | Dream War: An Interview with Ella Mine)                   

Like a Biblical psalmist, Mine narrates this season of suffering and her responses to it with raw honesty. Her album brought me to tears twice, which is pretty darn unusual (only one other album has ever pulled that off: Andy Gullahorn’s 2018 record Everything as It Should Be). As someone who has suffered from debilitating mental illness, Mine’s songs resonated with me on a deep level. I expect to revisit them often in years to come. 

Frederick Buechner wrote, “The story of one of us is, in some measure, the story of us all.” By plumbing the depths of her own experience of disorientation, Ella Mine offers us a new lens to examine our own struggles. Her story raises important questions: When waves of suffering threaten to overwhelm us, how do we keep our heads above water? How do we cling to hope when all we see around us is chaos? The tagline of Dream War asks the question this way: “How can we again dream, hope, or love when our first dreams have been crushed, our first hopes dashed, and our first loves ravaged?” For the rest of this post, I’ll be exploring Mine’s answers to those questions. In what I would argue is the finest album of 2020 so far, Mine charts a course that the rest of us can follow – a path which doesn’t lead us away from our hardships and heartbreaks, but rather towards them, into the very heart of the sea. 

I. Going Under

Psalm 130 opens with a cry for help: “Out of the depths I cry to you, O Lord! O Lord, hear my voice! Let your ears be attentive to the voice of my pleas for mercy!” (v. 1-2). The author of this ancient Hebrew song is drowning in suffering. Not only that, but he’s so far down that his only recourse is to plead with God for mercy. He harbors no illusions about his ability to swim back to the surface, no fantasies about his capacity to control the waves. Barring miraculous intervention, he’s sunk. 

Like Psalm 130, the songs of Dream War are filled with sea imagery. The first, “Intro // Tedious + Brief,” uses the sea as a metaphor for life itself, which is characterized by both wonder and danger. The chaos that lurks beneath the surface can’t dissuade Ella Mine from wanting to experience the water: “Though there are shadows dancing just beneath the waves / I wanna jump in / I wanna jump in anyway.” In the album’s second track, “Tender World I.,” Mine expresses her enchantment with the world’s beauty. She longs to love deeply and live fully alive: “What a tender world / What a tender world / Wanna give my heart up / To you.” Yet, she acknowledges that the sea of life is inherently unpredictable, and she knows that sailing it is a risky enterprise: “What a wild way, what a frightening game / We play in dreams / We send our hearts out on the waves / In pure belief.” Despite this recognition of risk, Mine is drawn to the promise and possibility of the ocean. 

Then, suddenly, things go horribly wrong. In the album’s third track, “Wolves (Ved Dora Mi),” we witness the entrance of hallucinations into Mine’s world, personified as hungry beasts that gnaw and scrape at the door of Mine’s bedroom. The terror of this experience sends shock waves through the waters of Mine’s dreams. Gone is the glistening ocean of promise, now replaced by a roiling sea of chaos. In the following song, “Dream War,” Mine is overwhelmed by her nightmares: “Calling off the dream war, ’cause I / Can’t keep the waves from breaking on this shore / Calling off the dream war, ’cause I / Already lost the dreams I was fighting for.” The same world that filled the sails of Mine’s dreams with its wonder has dashed those dreams on the rocks of its violence. The fifth track, “Don’t Make Me Go Back There,” opens with a haunting statement that captures the singer’s loss of innocence: “I don’t want to close my eyes / I don’t want to dream again.” 

As the album progresses, Mine’s disorientation intensifies. In the seventh song, she presents listeners with an unforgettable image: “There’s a bridge under water / And a flood running over.” Her escape route itself has been submerged. She’s at the mercy of the tide. 

Mine’s lyrics remind listeners that we have far less control over the circumstances of our lives than we tend to believe. Life on this planet is characterized by chaos. While suffering strikes us all, the nature and extent and timing of that suffering are as uncertain as the sea in a storm. And while some hardships can be bulldozed by sheer willpower, the kind of suffering that Mine’s songs and Psalm 130 describe is completely overwhelming – a pit far too deep to climb out from on one’s own. Simplistic slogans and ready-made solutions are of no use here. As Derek Kidner puts it, “Self-help is no answer to the depths of distress, however comforting it may be in the shallows of self-pity.” Faced with relentless hurt, we inevitably start asking big questions, which pull back the curtain of our lives and probe for meaning beyond it: “Why me?” “Why now?” “What did I do to deserve this?” “Where is God?” Paul Simon of Simon & Garfunkel describes this reality beautifully in his song “Wartime Prayers”: 

It’s a hard time, but everybody knows
All about hard times, the thing is, what are you gonna do?
Well, you cry and try to muscle through
Try to rearrange your stuff
But when the wounds are deep enough, 
And it’s all that we can bear, 
We wrap ourselves in prayer

Despite our best-laid plans, and despite our American culture’s assurances to the contrary, each and every one of us will eventually face a mess that we can’t fix. Sooner or later, we all find ourselves in the depths, floundering and fighting for breath. When this happens, when our attempts to reach shore have left us utterly spent, what will we do? Ella Mine’s first answer to the problem of overwhelming suffering is to acknowledge that it’s just that – overwhelming. If we cling to the illusion of control, we’ll find it a heavier illusion than we expected, and we may find ourselves sinking even further beneath the waves. Letting go is a frightening alternative. However, for Mine and for the writer of Psalm 130, it’s the essential starting point. 

II. Swallowing Water

After pleading with God to rescue him from the depths of his suffering, the writer of Psalm 130 poses this question: “If you, O Lord, should mark iniquities, O Lord, who could stand?” (v. 3). Here, the psalmist acknowledges that the problems he’s facing aren’t just the result of forces beyond his control; they’re also the result of his own choices. The psalmist is painfully aware of his misdeeds, the wreckage that these actions have created, and his culpability before God. If he were impervious to the waters, puffed up and waterproofed like an inflatable raft, then he’d have nothing to worry about. However, he knows that he’s vulnerable to the waves – that the same darkness which swirls around him is capable of rushing into him, filling his lungs, and plunging him even deeper into the sea. 

Midway through Dream War, Ella Mine’s reflections take a similar turn. Her song “Waters Rise” begins with these questions: 

Where you go in the night,
Would you go in daylight?
Have you seen on your way
Affections your choices have made?
And the heart is caught in the crossfire
Of dreams, but dreams are just desire

Here, Mine reveals that her nightmares aren’t just terrifying because of their foreignness, but also, in a sense, because of their familiarity. Like the waters of Psalm 130, these nightmares have exposed something in the songwriter’s heart – namely, its vulnerability to misguided and destructive desires. According to Mine, these twisted affections are the product of her own choices. Her dreams haven’t created new desires out of nothingRather, they’ve revealed, amplified, and corrupted desires which already existed, lurking below the surface like hungry sharks. In the song “Dream War,” Mine confesses her fear that these dark desires will begin to influence her actions: “If I’m scared then I’m scared of what I might design.” 

As Mine’s lyrics suggest, seasons of overwhelming suffering often act like wrecking balls, demolishing our defenses and unearthing parts of ourselves that we tend to ignore or hide. Think about this past year: battered by waves of hardship and controversy, how has our society responded? If we’re honest, we’ve got to admit that the fault lines we see around us – the riots and racial divides, the bickering and name-calling on social media, the disillusionment and distrust of political leaders, the panic and insensitivity surrounding responses to COVID-19 – aren’t new things. These cracks in our country’s foundations have existed for decades, even centuries in the case of racial injustice. Ignored for too long, such fractures have a way of asserting themselves during times of crisis. And before you or I start pointing fingers, pinning blame for our misfortunes on the shortcomings of everyone around us, we would do well to examine ourselves – to assess how we respond to inconveniences, upended plans, disagreements, and people who get on our nerves. If we do, we’ll be faced with the inescapable fact of our own flaws and failures. We’re part of the problem, after all. The chaos that we see in the world resides in us, too. As Russian author and political activist Alexander Solzhenitsyn wrote, “The line separating good and evil passes not through states, nor between classes, nor between political parties either – but right through every human heart.” 

The storm clouds that’ve been gathering throughout Dream War finally erupt in a devastating duo of songs, which come barreling at the listener like a runaway locomotive. The first, “Where Is She Now?,”borrows imagery from Shakespeare’s Macbeth. Late in that play, there’s a scene where Lady Macbeth is sleepwalking after arranging the murder of Scotland’s king. In the throes of a dream, she tries desperately to wash imaginary blood from her hands. Ella Mine applies this scene to her own story, emphasizing the terrifying persistence of her own guilt: 

Uh oh, there’s blood on my hands
I dreamed I killed a man
Oh memory, wash away
My knife, see not the wound, see not the wound you make…

Out, out, damned spot! Out! Away!
Wash, wash, my lady, wash, I say
I’ve seen in sleep
What, will these hands never be clean?

The next track, “Sound + Fury,”begins with a death knell. It borrows lines from Macbeth’s famous monologue, which occurs shortly after he receives news of his wife’s suicide. Here, Mine’s despair reaches its crescendo. Drowning in the depths of suffering, both suffering beyond her control and suffering of her own making, she can’t see any reason to hope. She shouts out: “Tomorrow and tomorrow gets more frightening all the time / We cry, ‘Out, brief candle! There’s no good for you to light.'” As in Psalm 130, Mine’s second response to the problem of overwhelming suffering is confession: an honest examination of personal brokenness. She recognizes that the chaos of the world is inextricably intertwined with the chaos of her own heart. After battling the waves of both of these seas, she finds herself unable to surmount them. Listeners are left with the strains of “Sound + Fury” ringing in their ears, wondering what possible resolution there could be to the dilemmas Mine has presented. 

III. Coming Up for Air 

Like most Biblical lament songs, Psalm 130 concludes with a turn towards hope. Having lamented his suffering, confessed his sins, and urged God to rescue him, the psalmist clings to the belief that God will act: “I wait for the Lord, my soul waits, and in his word I hope; my soul waits for the Lord, more than watchmen for the morning, more than watchmen for the morning. Oh Israel, hope in the Lord! For with the Lord there is steadfast love, and with him is plentiful redemption. And he will redeem Israel from all his iniquities” (v. 5-8). 

Mine’s own turn towards hope begins slowly, almost imperceptibly. The climax of Dream War, “Wheel of Love,”opens with a set of questions that summarize the record’s themes:

Honestly, tell me, is it better to believe
That good exists on some far out shore 
And set your course for the open sea?

Honestly, tell me, is it better to dream and
Be dashed again against the cliffs
And cast under the waves again? 

Most of us have probably heard these famous lines by the poet Alfred, Lord Tennyson: “Tis better to have loved and lost / Than never to have loved at all.” In “Wheel of Love,” Ella Mine dares to ask whether this statement is true. Are the joys of love really worth the costs of love? Is it truly worthwhile to love the world when life as we know it is ravaged by forces of darkness and decay, when the things that we treasure are torn from us, when our best efforts to love are scarred by failure and heartbreak? These questions might seem unnecessarily dismal. However, those who have navigated seasons of intense grief will resonate with their honesty. 

In the chorus of her song, Mine depicts love as a massive wheel, which inevitably chews up and spits out all who come close to it, changing them forever in the process. Those who keep their distance from the gear escape its peril and pain. However, they must face the alternative burden of loneliness: 

This wheel of love is turning slowly
So you love and you lose or you live your life lonely
And what you give, oh you know it might not come back to you, so you
Give it up freely, baby, or you guard it so tight that no one can get through
In the dark of your eyes and the shadow of your wall
You don’t hear the cries of the people as they fall
From the top of the wheel and are crushed by the gear
Alive in love 
Dreaming and trying, believing and buying
Hurt by love
Broken and frightened, loving and dying
Remade by love

As these lines wash over the listener, light begins to break over the surface of the sea. Mine’s struggles haven’t disappeared. The waters still roil around her, threatening to submerge her again. Yet, in a way that is at once subtle and seismic, her perspective on the storm has changed. Faced with the unbearable option of loneliness, of turning inward and shutting herself off from others in order to escape pain, Mine is reminded of why she ventured out to sea in the first place. She was made to love – kindled with yearning, designed for community with others, hand-crafted in the image of the God whose very essence is self-giving loyalty (Genesis 1:27, 1 John 4:7-8). She can’t deny this purpose any more than a fish can deny its gills. Rather than drowning her longing for love, Mine’s losses have deepened and hallowed that longing. The depths of her sorrow at love’s loss have reminded her that, like a “far out shore,” real love exists on the horizon and is really worth pursuing. 

In the following song, “Fire,”Mine acknowledges the dangers of love again: “I can’t love in this world…Without a fight / That’ll wear me down.” Then, like the author of Psalm 130, she turns her gaze upward, urging God to renew her strength: “I’ll run again / I’ll run again / Replace the fire.” Faced with the heavy costs of love, Mine gives her best answer to the problem of overwhelming suffering, which turns out to be the old answer, after all: Tis better to have loved and lost than never to have loved. 

Earlier, in her song “Walls,”Mine sings these words: “If I had held my head above the rising tide / I wouldn’t have to hold this breath so far inside.” In her interview with Chris Thiessen of the Rabbit Room, Mine explained these lyrics:

“Dream War” is full of ocean and water imagery because in those moments of clarity, it was like getting my head above water before being thrown back under the sea. I would take the deepest breath of air that I possibly could. Then, back under the waves, I would hold my breath as long as I could. In the recovery community, they call that sort of cycle “windows and waves.” In the windows, I would find truth and bury it inside of me. Not bury as in hide it, but as in secure it somewhere safe so that when I feel like I can’t reach it, I can still remember that it exists.

How does Mine hold on to hope in the midst of chaos? Like the author of Psalm 130, she rehearses God’s promises of redemption, breathing them in and clinging to them with all she’s got. She remembers truth and beauty. Like watchmen on a rampart, she looks to the horizon, and she waits for the dawn. 

Mine doesn’t answer all the questions surrounding her suffering, because she can’t. She doesn’t know why God has allowed it. She may never know. But two things she does know: First, she can’t live on the land, safe and solitary and untouched by heartbreak. She was made to brave the sea, with all of its storm clouds and breakers and tides. Second, her only hope for rescue from the depths of suffering – both the suffering of life’s waves and the suffering caused by her own failures – is the God who made the sea. This same God beckons to her (and to all of us) from the far out shore, inviting her to come further up and further in, promising that the destination is worth the perils of the journey. 

Epilogue: Dream Again

boat sailing in body of water

There’s a reason for Ella Mine’s belief that God is at work in her suffering. In the Gospel of Luke, we’re told a story about a group of men who got caught in a storm at sea. These men were seasoned sailors. They recognized the severity of the storm. They knew that, barring a miracle, they were sunk. Fighting to steer through the swells, they woke one of their company, who’d been sleeping on the floor of the boat. Climbing to his feet, this man uttered a single phrase – “Peace, be still” – and the storm ceased. The waves ground to a halt. The boat stopped moving. Shocked, the sailors turned to one another and asked the natural question: “Who then is this, that he commands even winds and water, and they obey him?” (Luke 8:25). 

The answer to their question can be found earlier in Scripture, tucked within an ancient prophecy made by God to people caught in the midst of overwhelming suffering: “When you pass through the waters, I will be with you; and through the rivers, they shall not overwhelm you…” (Isaiah 43:2). There is comfort in knowing that the same God who controls the sea also controls each of our storms. There is also comfort in knowing that he has promised to carry us through them. But what about the here and now, where our prayers for rescue are met with silence, where our best efforts at faith fall woefully short, where our deepest questions go unanswered? I’ve heard dozens of sermons on this particular story. However, few of them have highlighted the aspect of it that I find most comforting. Before stilling the storm, the maker of the sea rides in the boat. He ventures out with us into the depths. He takes on our humanity and suffers alongside us in the midst of life’s storms, enduring the chaos of the waves. He enters into our worst nightmares and invites us, come hell or high water, to dream again. His presence, more than anything else, is the reason for our hope. This is why the moment of Dream War that first brought me to tears was the bridge of the song “Wheel of Love,” where Ella Mine sings these words: 

I won’t take this burden from you
Only ride with you along the way
And you can sail this sinking vessel
If you set your sight above the waves

Fireworks (An Autumn Prayer)

The street is slick with rain 
as I make my way through the neighborhood 
past shuttered windows and closed doors. 
I’m headed to the place where the road bends 
for a visit. 

It’s been a while since we talked. 

Leaves skid dryly across the road to my right 
like rustling stalks of corn, 
like a letter as it’s opened. 
I watch them tumble end over end, 
the detritus of some recent cannon blast 
from a war that someone lost – 
flower petals at a funeral. 
Under a steel-grey sky, 
blackbirds wheel up from the pavement, whirling 
like an omen. 

I’ve already started the conversation 
because we’ve only got so much time. 
The skies above me are weeping 
and while the rainwater is gentle against the earth 
it’s still a goodbye. 

We’ve been here so many times. 
Why doesn’t it get easier?  

I’ve arrived at the tree line 
and said only a fragment of what there is to say. 
My eyes are on my shoes. 
When I finally look up, my part of the conversation 
and that old, familiar ache 
are cut short. 

In the distance, 
through the curtain of rain, 
I see your trees. 

Who set your forest on fire? 

The leaves of oaks and aspens 
are going up in flames, 
sputtering and sizzling in the downpour. 
They light up like kerosene lanterns, 
then burst open like fireworks, 
spraying ash on the sidewalks. 
The blaze crackles with livid color 
like a neon sign, 
cherry red and burnt orange 
and liquid gold. 
Branches above me disappear 
in a maelstrom of light. 
Under the edge of the inferno, 
leaves careen between tree trunks 
like dragonflies in wind, flung outward 
into empty space 
like paper airplanes. 

I start looking around desperately. 
Where have you gone? 
Where, at a time like this? 

And then, 
between the trees and tangled brush, 
I see you. 
You’re running headlong through the wall of heat 
with a box of matches in hand, 
striking them one by one 
against the tree trunks 
and flinging them upward 
into the boughs. 

You started this fire. 
You’re launching these fireworks, 
torching your trees, 
sending your forest up in smoke. 

Through the din of the explosions 
I catch the sound of your voice. 
I thought you’d be crying this time of year, 
but you’re laughing like a little kid 
as you light fuses, 
grinning ear to ear through the gunpowder air 
as you catch my eye, 
saying, “Watch this!” 
So I do. 

I watch until the blasts have died away 
and the branches are guttering like candle flames 
in the rain. 
I inhale the smell of burnt paper. 
A smile flickers on my lips, kindled 
by your bewildering laughter. 
And then I turn and head for home, 
chuckling in disbelief. 
It’s quiet again. 
I fish for words, open my mouth to speak – 

The wind kicks up 
and another volley booms from the eaves of the wood, 
only this time the flames are all around me, 
golden shrapnel whizzing through the air 
and drifting down like snowflakes. 

This is downright excessive. 

Dragons are circling overhead 
on wings like distant thunder. 
They flare their nostrils, belching sparks, 
dancing and diving together, churning 
like waves in a storm. 
I’ve seen enough firework displays 
to know a finale when I see one. 
A lump forms in my throat 
because here in the rain you’re pulling out all the stops. 
This is your send-off, isn’t it? 
You want me to pay attention. Be still. 
There’s only so much wood to burn. 

And I need to take my shoes off. 

It’s still raining 
as I trudge back through the neighborhood 
past shuttered windows and closed doors. 
The debris of your fireworks are plastered across the pavement, 
soaked in rainwater. 
My ears are still ringing 
and I think I know now why you asked me to visit 
on a day like this. 
You wanted to go out with a bang, 
and you wanted me to see it. 

Thanks for the invitation.

August, Adam Duritz, and the Art of Rejoicing in the Rain

At some point during my college years, I started going for long walks in the rain. While this practice may sound strange to you, it wasn’t that unusual as far as I was concerned. I’d loved rainfall for as long as I could remember. Everything about it was magical to me – the pattering of droplets on windowpanes and pavement, the smell of damp soil, the drumbeat of distant thunder. As a teenager, I would open the door of my family’s garage and set up a folding chair so I could sit and watch the rain. I couldn’t have disagreed more with folks who grumbled about stormy weather. In my mind, rain was cause for rejoicing.

As my rainy-day walks grew into a habit, my relationship with rain started to change. On these trips, I would often talk with God about things that were weighing on my heart. I told him about my loneliness and my aimlessness, about my desire for romance and my regrets after break-ups, about my concerns for my family and my worries about the future. Over time, these walks became spaces set aside for longing and lament – times for pondering what might have been and wrestling with God about what might yet be. Somehow, amidst the sights and sounds and smells of rainfall, the notion that God was “near to the brokenhearted” (Psalm 34:18) seemed a little bit easier to believe.

For many people, these past few months have been a time of deep sorrow. Some are grieving the loss of loved ones whose lives were cut short by COVID-19. Others are lamenting painful changes that followed in the wake of the virus, upending life as they knew it. Still others are mourning the wounds of systemic racism, which have haunted our nation’s history since the days of slavery and run far deeper than many of us have been taught to believe. Recently, my own family has been struggling with the effects of chronic illness – a degenerative disease that kept my mother bedridden throughout quarantine. In Philippians 4:4, we read these words: “Rejoice in the Lord always. I will say it again: rejoice!” Yet, in rainy seasons, when storms roll in and refuse to let up, we might find ourselves wondering whether this command is at all possible to fulfill.

During these months of pandemic and protest, I’ve been digging into the music of my favorite band: Counting Crows. I discovered their debut album August & Everything After a couple years ago (as a youngster born mid-way through the ’90s, I came late to the party). While I wasn’t sure what to make of it initially, it has slowly become one of my all-time favorite records. I happen to think it’s one of the best records ever made. Recently, God has been using this album to teach me some surprising truths about mourning, melancholy, and the art of rejoicing in the rain.

The Discipline of Mourning

Lyrically and thematically, August & Everything After is saturated with rainfall. Rain or storms are mentioned in five of the songs, including the titles “Rain King” and “Raining in Baltimore.” The album is autobiographical, taking its title from the month when lead singer and lyricist Adam Duritz was born. On the whole, it’s an exercise in mourning. Duritz is famous for writing melancholy ballads, andhis band’s debut record is chock-full of sad, sad songs. With startling honesty, Duritz invites listeners into his personal sorrows: his battle with loneliness, his struggle with mental illness, and his romantic heartbreaks. Sadness isn’t peripheral for Duritz. It’s a badge that he wears on his sleeve – a characteristic as recognizable as his dreadlocks. In a sense, the songwriter has built a career out of walking in the rain. 

While some critics have dismissed Counting Crows’ songs as unnecessarily dismal, the band has stayed true to their artistic vision, refusing to cater to music industry trends. Their work isn’t confined by its mournful tone. Rather, the songs of August & Everything After are bold explorations of the caves and chasms in the human heart. Traveling where few dare to tread, Duritz is able to pen lyrics that are at once vulnerable and profound, like these lines from “Perfect Blue Buildings”:

I’ve got bones beneath my skin, Mister
There’s a skeleton in every man’s house
Beneath the dust and love and sweat that hang on everybody
There’s a dead man trying to get out

Or take these lines from “Raining in Baltimore,” which describe the challenge of reckoning with grief in a world that feels oblivious to our losses:

I get no answers and I don’t get no change
It’s raining in Baltimore, baby
But everything else is the same

Like the songs of August & Everything After, the pages of Scripture are soaked through with the practice of mourning. The ragged ache of Duritz’s vocals echoes the groans of the psalmists, who regularly cried out to God with songs of lament. These works of art, which were marked by brutal honesty, were expressions of both individual sorrow and communal grief. The sheer volume of lament songs in Scripture reveals the psalmists’ belief that there was “a time to weep” (Ecclesiastes 3:4) – that rainy seasons were intrinsic to life under the sun. Jesus himself spoke about lament, teaching his followers that those who mourn are “blessed” by their creator (Matthew 5:4). In the Beatitudes, we see that mourning is a spiritual discipline that is meant to be cultivated. Like meekness and mercy, peacemaking and poverty of spirit, it’s something characteristic of believers – a defining aspect of their interactions with a broken world. Jesus exemplified the discipline of mourning in his interactions with others (John 11:35, Luke 19:41) and in his prayer life (Hebrews 5:7). He was also called a “man of sorrows” (Isaiah 53:3), a description which could just as easily be applied to Adam Duritz. For followers of Christ, lament isn’t optional. Rather, it’s a vital part of our personal and corporate worship.

As I’ve revisited August & Everything After, I’ve been challenged by Adam Duritz’s willingness to bare his soul. Faced with personal heartache, do I hide feelings of doubt, anger, or grief? Or do I offer my emotions to God, trusting him to handle their jagged edges? Faced with the fallout of systemic injustice, am I reluctant to engage in difficult conversations that highlight my own complacency? Or am I seeking to listen and learn – to get proximate to those who are hurting so that I can “weep with those who weep” (Romans 12:15)?

The Power of Mourning

green plant

While Counting Crows’ songs are consistently overcast, they’re also riven by shafts of light. More than anything else, what keeps me coming back to August & Everything After is the redemption that lurks at the edges of the lyrics, waiting to ambush listeners when they least expect it. Rather than stifling this spark of hope, the stormy segments of the record only augment its beauty. Without meeting the wanderer who treads the rainy streets of “Omaha,” we wouldn’t appreciate the statement of homecoming that closes out the song. Without the cynical tug-of-war that characterizes the relationship in “Anna Begins,” we wouldn’t be surprised when “kindness falls like rain” and knits reluctant hearts together. Without the wailing confessions of “Rain King,” we wouldn’t understand Duritz’s longing to fly “into the burning heart of God.” And without the restless ache that pervades the album as a whole, we wouldn’t feel the warmth of the album’s final track, which breaks over the preceding valley of shadows with all the promise of a sunrise.

Like Duritz’s lyrics, the laments of God’s people are imbued with purpose. Over and over again in Scripture, the cries of suffering and oppressed people move God to act on their behalf. Additionally, the practice of godly mourning is accompanied by a promise: “Those who plant in tears will harvest with shouts of joy. They weep as they go to plant their seed, but they sing as they return with the harvest” (Psalm 126:5-6). In these verses, we see that the disciplines of mourning and rejoicing aren’t incompatible. Rather, they’re inseparable. Only by acknowledging and grieving the depth of our brokenness can we appreciate the depth of God’s grace in Christ. Only by reckoning with the wounds of the world can we appreciate the beauty of God’s promised redemption. Like the grim passages of August & Everything After, the storm winds of our own stories and songs end up stoking the fires of our hope (Romans 5:3-5), kindling our longing for the Kingdom that is coming. Just as rain prepares soil for the abundance of harvest, so the groans of God’s people prepare their hearts for the abundance of new creation.

The Beauty of Mourning

person about to touch glass

We may understand that rain serves a purpose. But what about times of despair? What about those seasons when we can’t see any growth, when we struggle to believe that it’s even happening, or when there’s so much rain that the things we’ve planted start to wilt and decay?

As I’ve explored the music of Counting Crows, I’ve noticed that few of their songs have happy endings. Tracks like “Round Here,” “Sullivan Street,” “Ghost Train,” and “Raining in Baltimore” are bookended by brokenness, littered with the wreckage of dashed hopes and damaged relationships. While Adam Duritz may long for redemption, he’s got no clear road map for how to get there. His lyrics offer far more questions than answers. Yet, I’m encouraged by his willingness to give life to these songs – to fill them with vivid metaphors and craft beautiful melodies for them, despite their lack of resolution. No matter what the music industry tells him, Duritz clings to the conviction that his broken places – the parts of himself that he fears, regrets, hates, or struggles to make sense of – are worth singing about.

Most of Counting Crows’ songs remind me of Psalm 88. The writer of this psalm is all alone. He can’t see any end to his suffering, and he feels abandoned by his creator. Unlike most Biblical laments, his song concludes with a statement of profound heartbreak: “You have taken from me friend and neighbor – darkness is my closest friend.” Why would God choose to include such a song in Scripture? While I can’t be sure of the reason, I think the answer lies somewhere along the lines of these lyrics, which are taken from Amy Grant’s song “Better than a Hallelujah”:

We pour out our miseries
God just hears a melody
Beautiful the mess we are
The honest cries of breaking hearts

Adam Duritz says something similar in his song “Goodnight L.A.”:

I don’t mind the dark discovering the day
‘Cause the night is a beautiful bright blue and grey

Our creator has a knack for seeing beauty where others fail to see it – in wilderness and wayfarers, in stables and shepherds, in outcasts and outlaws. Could it be that he also sees beauty in our mourning? According to Psalm 56:8, God treats the cries of his children with reverence, gathering them like precious treasures: “You keep track of all my sorrows. You have collected all my tears in your bottle. You have recorded each one in your book” (Psalm 56:8). We don’t have to package our emotions in ways that make them more palatable to God. Our maker meets us where we are. He walks with us in the middle of the rain, treating our storms as sacred spaces. He receives our laments – even the unresolved ones – as gifts to be cherished. Not only that, but the Spirit also groans with us, weaving our tears into his own song of lament (Romans 8:26). Like Counting Crows, God is in the business of mining gold from the caves and chasms in our souls, turning our broken places into works of art.

blue yellow and black graffiti on wall

These past few months have been a painful time. Surrounded by sorrow, I yearn for the renewal of all things – for the day when injustice, sickness, and death are distant memories. The clouds haven’t parted yet. Until they do, I’ll keep walking in the rain, following in the footsteps of my savior. I’ll remember where the rain is bound for and scan the ground for signs of life. And when the fields are barren and swampy, when I can’t believe that anything will grow from the muck, I’ll watch the pattering of droplets on pavement, breathe the smell of damp soil, and listen for the drumbeat of thunder. I’ll remember that there is a time to weep, and that rain is still cause for rejoicing.

Emmaus

I read some poetry today
by a man who talked about the earth
like an old friend.
It was just a neat idea
until I stepped onto the deck
and heard in the creaking of wooden boards
the tones of a voice I recognized,
until I felt in the wind
that welcome breath of soil after rain,
until I saw in the patchwork quilt of houses and hills
the creases of a familiar face.

I ran into another old friend
later in the day
while playing soccer with my little brother.
It was just a game
until the ball came skidding toward me
and my eyes traced its flight,
until my hips swiveled and adjusted
to the tilt of the earth,
until my toes scraped dirt
for just an instant
and caught the edge of the ball
just so,
until the ball curved away across the yard
and straight to my brother
like I was connecting the dots between us.
After the game,
while walking home through the neighborhood,
I felt a twinge of pain in my hip
and resumed that unexpected conversation.

Throughout the day,
the thoughts came rumbling past
one after another
like train cars.
I thought about my college friends
and our recent video chat,
about the words that came so easy
and the spaces in between
when nothing needed to be said.
I felt that familiar longing for someone
whose eyes could answer mine
like a well-traveled road.
I heard the voice of my grandfather
like the warmth of a fireplace
or a way back home.

I like to think
that those two disciples felt something similar
on the road to Emmaus –
that warmth and wonder and wild joy
of recognition –
when the stranger at their table broke bread
and, for just a moment,
right before he disappeared,
they saw their friend again.

Ezra Pound once said,
 “What thou lov’st well
shall not be reft from thee.”
I think he was right.
How wonderful to know
that with each of these old friends
there will be a reunion.

The Celts, the Coronavirus, and the Kingdom of God

With all the news and chaos surrounding the recent spread of the Coronavirus, you may have forgotten that today is St. Patrick’s day. I sure haven’t. March 17 is an opportunity for the people of the Emerald Isle to celebrate their history and cultural heritage. It’s also an opportunity for those of us who wish we were Irish to do the same thing vicariously. I’ve been a wannabe Irishman for a long, long time.

Where did this weird longing to be Irish come from? Part of it springs from a lifelong preference for the color green (which may spring from the fact that when my siblings and me were young, our parents color-coded the family’s plastic cups, and I got stuck with the green one). Another part of it springs from a love of rain, thunderstorms, and the sea. A big chunk of it springs from an appreciation of Irish music, which is one of my love languages. No other forms of music wake my heart up like Celtic reels, jigs, and ballads do. Come to think of it, a good seventy-five percent of my love for Irish culture is probably traceable to the bagpipes (I’m only slightly kidding). I’ve told my family and close friends that when I die, I want my body to be laid on a raft, set on fire, and pushed out into Lake Michigan in the traditional Viking fashion, preferably to the tune of bagpipes (I know that Nordic and Celtic cultures are pretty different, but they’re also linked in my mind because of the How to Train Your Dragon movies. Who knew that Vikings had Scottish accents?).

Despite my desires, I can’t claim to be bona-fide Irish. My grandpa on my mom’s side was raised in the Dutch culture of West Michigan, and he always used to joke that his family was “English, Irish, French, German, and one-hundred percent Dutch.” A relative of ours recently did the DNA tracking thing, and while it turns out that our biggest percentage is Irish (sorry, Grandpa), our ancestry is actually, as with most Americans, a hodgepodge. Nevertheless, the longing for deeply-rooted ties to a specific place and people runs deep. Whether or not most of my ancestors actually sailed across the stormy Atlantic from “Paddy’s Green Shamrock Shore,” I like to believe that they did, and I view Ireland as a kind of ancestral homeland.

The Story

This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is aldo-de-la-paz-d6u2_u02FIo-unsplash.jpg

Last week, my little sister and I watched my all-time favorite animated movie, The Secret of Kells. If you haven’t seen it yet, you need to. Set in medieval Ireland, the film is based on the true story of Catholic monks who preserved and illustrated sacred Christian texts during the Viking invasions of the 9th century. Its story follows Brendan, an orphan boy who lives in a monastery called the Abbey of Kells. Once, the land surrounding the abbey was a place of peace and beauty. Farmers tilled the soil, children played on the grass, and monks decorated their scriptures with breathtaking illuminations. But those days are gone. Viking tribesmen are wreaking havoc along the shores of Britain, pillaging and plundering wherever they go. With the threat of destruction looming nearer, the abbot of Kells – an imposing fellow named Cellach – has enlisted his people in a desperate project: the construction of a massive stone wall encircling the monastery and the surrounding farmlands. As the abbot’s nephew, Brendan is instructed to assist with the building of the wall.

However, another monk has recently arrived in Kells and captured Brendan’s attention: Brother Aidan, a spry and whiskery old scholar whose illuminations of Biblical texts are the stuff of legend. Fleeing from the ruins of his island home, which was ravaged by the Vikings, Brother Aidan has carried a treasure to Kells: a copy of the Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John that is called the Book of Iona. The wizened artist is working to finish the manuscript’s Chi-Ro page (Chi and Ro are the first two letters of Christ’s name in Latin), which is to be his masterpiece. He asks Brendan to help him by gathering ingredients for ink from the nearby forest. Dazzled by the beauty of the book, Brendan agrees to help, even though he has been forbidden to leave the abbey. When he ventures beyond the wall, Brendan discovers something incredible – a world of magic and mystery, of fairies and fantastical creatures, buried deep in the tangled heart of the woods.

You can probably guess where this is going. Conflict soon ensues between Abbot Cellach and Brother Aidan, both of whom feel responsible to care for Brendan. In Cellach’s mind, Aidan’s priorities are deeply misplaced. These are dark times. Many lives are at stake, and practical threats demand practical solutions. While they may have filled life with meaning in the past, things like artwork and leisure have no relevance to the present. In Aidan’s mind, Cellach’s priorities have been ensnared by fear. For the illuminator, the stuff that the abbot has chosen to ignore – things like art, wonder, and the appreciation of beauty – are just as relevant as they ever were, if not more so. As tensions rise, Brendan is forced to choose where his loyalties lie. If he continues to visit the forest and help Brother Aidan illuminate the Book of Iona, he risks facing his uncle’s wrath. All the while, the Viking invaders march steadily nearer.

As I reflected on The Secret of Kells, I couldn’t help thinking about its resonance to our current social climate. Like the Viking raids of medieval Europe, the spread of Coronavirus has caused a tidal wave of fear and sparked controversy regarding how people should respond to the threat. Should we brace ourselves for the epidemic, or should we continue life as usual? Is Abbot Cellach right, or is Brother Aidan? The conflict between these two characters is a deeply illuminating one. When examined closely, it has some important things to teach us about our responses to life’s threats and about the mysterious thing that Christians call “the Kingdom of God.”

The Abbot

gray bricks wall

Let’s start with Abbot Cellach. Underneath his grim exterior, the abbot is an easy man to sympathize with. As the social and spiritual leader of Kells, Cellach feels deeply responsible for the well-being of his parishioners, and he works tirelessly to protect them. Furthermore, the Vikings are a real and terrifying threat. If the people of Kells don’t take action, they’re likely to be slaughtered like those who live nearer to the coast. 

Like many others, I was quick to downplay the seriousness of Coronavirus and reluctant to change anything about my daily routine. However, regardless of what you or I may think about the actual scope and danger of the Coronavirus epidemic, the fact remains that many reasonable people are very concerned about it. Additionally, many well-trained medical personnel are urging caution out of concerns for the elderly, the immunodeficient, and the chronically ill, all of whom have a significantly higher risk of severe sickness. Several members of my family fall into the second and third categories, and our family knows several other chronically ill families who are both concerned about the virus and discouraged by Facebook posts and articles that downplay the threat as “only affecting old and immunodeficient people.” While the virus may be significantly less dangerous for those of us who are young and well, this is no excuse for us to minimize the fears or suffering of those who are not. Even if some of the dangers of the virus have been exaggerated by the media, are we praying for those who have been or could be deeply impacted by the virus? Are we choosing to ignore the headlines and continue life as usual out of a desire for normalcy, or are we taking time to consider how our actions (or inaction, in the case of social distancing) could contribute to the well-being of the vulnerable?

According to the Book of Ecclesiastes, “There is a time for everything, and a season for every activity under the heavens” (Ecclesiastes 3:1). If this is true, then it follows that there are some times in our lives that require caution. Despite its beauty, our world is a dangerous and deeply broken place. Sometimes, caring for those we love requires carefulness, hard thinking, and a willingness to make some uncomfortable personal sacrifices. Abbot Cellach understands these things very well.

However, the abbot’s dispute with Brother Aidan sheds some light on the darker side of Cellach’s wall-building project. While leading his people, Cellach stands tall. Inside the seclusion of the monastery tower, where plans for Kells’ defenses are scribbled over the walls, Cellach’s shoulders are slumped. He carries a heavy burden. His remarks to his fellow monks are terse, and his willingness to listen to others is wearing thin. Once, the abbot was a gifted illuminator. Now, he has no time to spend with his nephew, no time to notice the remarkable book that Brother Aidan carries, no time to read the scriptures that once inspired him, and no time to glimpse the beauty of the trees beyond his wall. While his efforts to protect Kells are well-intentioned, it’s easy to see that they’re also driven by fear.

You and I have read enough news headlines, seen enough social media posts, and witnessed enough political and economic squabbles to know that our culture is saturated with worry. In times of peace and plenty, we’re told that life is short, that we have to “get ahead,” do something “important,” and insulate ourselves against any discomforts that could possibly come our way. In times of conflict and calamity, we’re told to protect ourselves, our belongings, and our way of life at any cost (even at the cost of a toilet-paper famine). While there’s nothing wrong with thoughtful preparation or stocking up on necessities, our constant stress and frenzied shopping sprees should prompt us to consider: Where have we placed our hope? When trouble comes, what do we instinctively turn to? If we’re relying on our own strength, our own brilliance, and our own resources, what do we do when these things aren’t enough?

Worry has a tendency to make us myopic, drawing our focus inward until all that we can see is our own problems. When we’re worried, we tend not to listen well to others. We tend not to notice the small moments of beauty and wonder that are woven throughout the fabric of our days. We tend to approach God as someone who can give us what we want, rather than someone to share life with. We also tend to devalue things that formerly filled us with gratitude – things like stories and songs. One of the reasons that I dropped my English major in college was the sinking feeling that it wasn’t useful or important – that the world had enough storytellers and that there were far more pressing things in the world which needed attending to. In some ways, my attitude mirrored Abbot Cellach’s: What use could pen and ink possibly have in a world that seemed to be falling apart everywhere I looked?

Like the fear-driven perspective of Abbot Cellach, my devaluing of the artist’s vocation was born out of a major blind spot. I had forgotten another truth in the Book of Ecclesiastes, one that Brother Aidan tells Brendan during a late-night conversation in the monastery – “There’s nothing in this world but mist, and we will only be alive for a short while.” Our short lives are, as the author of Ecclesiastes repeatedly puts it, “vapor” or “breath” (hebel in Hebrew). This applies not only to the tools of our trades, but also to the big things that we fix our hopes upon – to the achievements that the world applauds and to our most determined efforts to heal the world’s brokenness. We have far less control over our lives than we like to believe. In the end, nothing in this world lasts. The tide comes in, the Vikings arrive on our shores, and time lays waste to our best-laid plans and projects. We may be able to insulate ourselves from suffering and death now, but not forever. Even Brother Aidan knows that the peace of Kells is temporary. He tells Cellach regarding the Vikings: “When they come, all that we can do is run and hope that we are fast enough.”

The Illuminator

In contrast to Abbot Cellach, Brother Aidan is sharply incongruous with the somber atmosphere of Kells. Though he understands the weightiness of the times (many of his Christian brothers were killed by the invaders), he carries himself lightly. He cracks jokes, strikes up conversations, and cares for his cat, Pangur Ban. While most of the adults of Kells are far too busy to play with children, Aidan invites young Brendan to participate in his work of illumination. While everyone around him is focused on big things – Vikings, invasions, and a giant wall – Aidan challenges Brendan to notice small things – the emerald ink of a tiny berry and the lace-like pattern on a butterfly’s wing. In spite of his surroundings, Aidan has chosen to live in gratitude and contentment, savoring God’s simple gifts.

Aidan’s character reminds me of another person whose life and teachings were marked by an appreciation for small things: Jesus Christ. Jesus lived during a time of great turmoil. And yet, when his followers were busy with more pressing matters, Jesus spent time interacting with little children (Mark 10:13-16). Rather than treating these kids as second-class citizens (as most in his culture would have) or pushing them to grow up and make something of themselves, Jesus honored and celebrated them where they were at. In a temple where rich people were donating huge sums of money, Jesus called his followers’ attention to a poor widow who was giving a single coin, which was all the wealth that she had to offer (Mark 12:41-44). He saw beyond the size of the donation to the heart behind the gift. Jesus also made time to share meals and conversations with “little people” whom his society devalued: beggars, prostitutes, disabled people, the chronically ill, and even a literal little dude like Zaccheus. He did this so regularly that some people called him “a glutton and a drunkard” (Matthew 11:19). Unlike the religious elite of his day, Jesus recognized the value of everyday activities to relationship-building. Additionally, he taught that the Maker of the universe was interested not only in the big stuff that society defined as “important,” but also in tiny things like the meals of birds and the colors of flower petals.

How should we respond to the troubles that come our way? While Jesus never told people to ignore weighty matters, he often pushed them to look beyond the surface of things. He encouraged them to slow themselves down and notice God’s handiwork in the mundane. He challenged them to see the significance of the simple: the beauty of nature, the joy of childhood, and the power of fellowship around a table. In short, Jesus taught people that God cares just as much about small things as he does about big things. Why did he do this? Jesus understood our tendency to become myopic. He knew that in times of suffering, we would forget the fact that God’s gracious hand is continually at work in the world, that even now Christ is sustaining the smallest parts of creation, right down to their molecules – “in him all things hold together” (Colossians 1:17). Jesus reminded people about God’s interest in small things to emphasize God’s control over big things, and to comfort us in the midst of our struggles with worry:

“Look at the birds of the air; they do not sow or reap or store away in barns, and yet your heavenly Father feeds them. Are you not much more valuable than they? Can any one of you by worrying add a single hour to your life?… And why do you worry about clothes? See how the flowers of the field grow. They do not labor or spin. Yet I tell you that not even Solomon in all his splendor was dressed like one of these. If that is how God clothes the grass of the field, which is here today and tomorrow is thrown into the fire, will he not much more clothe you – you of little faith?” (Matthew 6:26-30).

While the verse about flowers outdoing “Solomon in all his splendor” might seem like a slam on King Solomon (How would you like it if someone said that some plants were cooler than your royal wardrobe?), Solomon himself acknowledged the fleeting nature of worldly pursuits in the Book of Ecclesiastes – the “vanity” of things like fame, knowledge, achievement, wealth, and material pleasure. Like Christ, Solomon urged people to “fear God” above worldly threats (Ecclesiastes 12:13). Like Christ, he encouraged people to savor the simple joys of life, which are God’s good gifts to humanity: “Go, eat your bread with joy, and drink your wine with a merry heart, for God has already approved what you do… Enjoy life with the wife whom you love…” (Ecclesiastes 9:7,8).

As we prepare for the arrival of Coronavirus, Jesus’ words should remind Christians that we’re called to live with trust, gratitude, and contentment. Even in chaotic and unsettling times, we have so much to be thankful for. This world remains far more beautiful than it needs to be. Additionally, Jesus’ treatment of vulnerable people should prompt us to ask ourselves: Are we considering those whom our society is neglecting? Many of the homeless folks in our neighborhoods have higher risks of severe illness due to things like old age, mental illness, and immunodeficiency (the latter of which can be exacerbated by drug abuse or lack of access to health care). In the midst of our shopping, are we thinking about these people? Are we praying for them and asking God how he may be calling us to support them? Is our worry causing us to become self-focused, or is our relationship with Christ turning our gaze outward to our neighbors?

Ultimately, in Abbot Cellach’s mind, the Book of Iona is a foolish project. However, to Brother Aidan, it is something of extraordinary importance – “the book that turned darkness into light.” Brother Aidan understands something that the abbot hasn’t yet grasped: the reality of the Kingdom of God. In a time of great darkness, the old illustrator sees the Book of Iona as a beacon of hope. Rather than forgetting the scriptures, he has dedicated his life to preserving and sharing their sacred glow.

Jesus talked a whole lot about the Kingdom of God, which he described as God’s reign in human hearts (Luke 17:21). Often, he did so through stories called “parables.” Jesus described the Kingdom as something that was both incredibly small and incredibly powerful, like a tiny mustard seed (“the smallest of all seeds”) which blossoms into a massive tree, or a tiny bit of yeast that leavens a huge lump of dough (Matthew 13:31-34). He also depicted the Kingdom as something that was both hidden and extremely precious, like a treasure buried in the dirt or a beautiful pearl in a marketplace (Matthew 13:44-45). These parables suggest that God’s Kingdom is often unnoticed and underappreciated by the kingdoms of this world. However, for those who take time to examine its light, it’s a thing of intense beauty and immeasurable value. In the same passage where he urged his followers not to worry, Jesus also instructed them to live with the Kingdom of God in mind:

“So do not worry, saying ‘What shall we eat?’ or ‘What shall we drink?’ or “What shall we wear?’… For pagans run after all these things, and your heavenly Father knows that you need them. But seek first his kingdom and his righteousness, and all these things will be given to you as well.” (Matthew 6:31-34)

To those outside the faith (and even sometimes to us within), the message that Christians preach can seem incredibly foolish. Christians have placed their eternal hope in a Jewish rabbi who was tortured and killed in 1st-century Palestine, in the befuddling notion that this man was God in human flesh, and in the similarly confounding claim that he walked out of his own grave on Easter morning. However, for those who follow Christ, the Christian message is good news unlike any other. This was the same message that St. Patrick, the first Christian missionary to Ireland, carried with him on his journey. It’s an offer of grace that we could never hope to earn and new life that we could never have imagined. We live in a world ravaged by death and despair, by sin and suffering, by Vikings and viruses. However, those who follow Christ cling to the promise that, through the cross of our Lord and Savior, each and every one of these things has been conquered. We may lose the battle, but we have won the war. Through what Mother Theresa called “little acts of great love,” or what Gandalf the Grey called “the small, everyday deeds of ordinary folk” (Gandalf and Mother Theresa were pals, if you didn’t know), God’s Kingdom will continue to spread and take root in human hearts, turning darkness into light. I continue to struggle with worry, and I often forget about the promise of the Kingdom. When that happens, I’m thankful that God has provided gifts like pen and ink, stories like The Secret of Kells, and holidays like St. Patrick’s day to help me remember.

The Dance

man playing Turkish flute

I’m still moved every time I hear the music of bagpipes. While the instrument’s mournful, wailing tune may not be your cup of tea (and may even remind you of an enraged goose), I happen to think it’s the most beautiful sound in the world. One of my favorite things about Celtic music is how it can sound joyful and sorrowful at the same time. I mentioned this to a good friend once (looking at you, AA-Ron), and he told me that Celtic songs are often written in a scale that’s neither major nor minor. This gives them a bittersweet tone, which is accentuated by the fact that sad lyrics are often set to the dancing rhythms of jigs and reels. 
Those who have placed their trust in Christ look forward to the day when the kingdom will come in its fullness. We yearn for the Great Dance – the restoration of all that has been broken by sin and death. However, Jesus’ teachings remind us that the dance has already begun – indeed, is going on all around us – in the beauty of birds and flower petals, in the transformation of human hearts, and in the deeds of the everyday. If we listen closely, we might just hear the distant echoes of its music, calling to us like a country across the sea.